Which was more important to you? FA Cup or Premier League?

[Manchester1894]

[bigimg]http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-7VsLOfzLrd4/TzkTjzAWQFI/AAAAAAAAAbM/HFJiERAbfUQ/s1600/CarlosTevezFACupCity.jpeg[/bigimg]

OR

[bigimg]http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2012/05/14/article-2144359-1313CB6E000005DC-898_634x420.jpg[/bigimg]

FA Cup for me... first trophy in my City lifetime.

 

[fathellensbellend]

the cup felt important from a personal point of view and for a generation of fans, winning the league was equally as enjoyable, with far more magnitude.

enjoyed both equally but in completely different ways.

a trophy a season would be nice.

 

[moggymoz]

So when does Jeremy Beadle appear ...

 

[jimharri]

Difficult question. I was blessed to be at both and while May 13th 2012 is something that will stay with me to the grave, I believe that (for sheer importance) the Cup final may just shade it. For the simple reason that it got that bloody monkey off our backs about going for so long without winning a (major) trophy. And it got our players used to the philosophy of winning. I'm not saying that the FA Cup is anywhere as prestigious as the Premiership; it's not even close. But the OP wasn't asking that.

 

[njmcfc1894]

fa cup as 1st trophy ive seen but for the clubs long term future rthen the league more important.

 

[Blue Streak]

The FA Cup was fantastic as it ended the drought but for me personally I've always wanted to see City become Champions of England so the Premiership was a no brainer. And seeing the pain it is causing Rags at the minute is simply amazing. But I have the taste now and I want more. Hope the players retain the same desire.

 

[ForzaMancini]

The Premier League, definitely.

 

[carlos tevez is a blue]

It's like comparing fish N chips to a pot noddle both excellent but one shit over the other one.

The Premiership was my happiest moment in my life(above my son being born.)

 

[cookster]

It's like comparing fish N chips to a pot noddle both excellent but one shit over the other one.

The Premiership was my happiest moment in my life(above my son being born.)

This! With the exception of close family experiences, the best day of my life.

 

[Richard]

The FA Cup was fantastic as it ended the drought but for me personally I've always wanted to see City become Champions of England so the Premiership was a no brainer. And seeing the pain it is causing Rags at the minute is simply amazing. But I have the taste now and I want more. Hope the players retain the same desire.

Pretty much this. On the 13th of May, I went from the depths of despair to unrivelled ectasy in the space of 3 crazy minutes. No matter what we do in the coming seasons, I dont think that will ever be topped. The first one as they say is always the most special.