The Stone Roses/Ian Brown

[lafitz2008]

Pointless if they did without newer music,

No more All For One type shite please

 

[Banned Tosspot]

Pointless if they did without newer music,

I know Reni.

Ain't happening.

 

[Man_City_Loyal]

I know Reni.

Ain't happening.

cool.

 

[shackattack]

First album was brilliant but second coming was average by their standards. 2 albums in as many decades tells you all you need to know. Maybe their standards were too high. Reni was an amazing drummer and other 3 were very talented but as a whole unit they lacked something.

 

[Banned Tosspot]

Massively overrated band but Love Spreads is as great as How Soon is Now? by the equally overrated Smith's x

 

[BlueMoonRisin’]

First album was brilliant but second coming was average by their standards. 2 albums in as many decades tells you all you need to know. Maybe their standards were too high. Reni was an amazing drummer and other 3 were very talented but as a whole unit they lacked something.

First album is more melodic and pop sounding. Second coming is more deep and moody. I prefer second coming.

 

[shackattack]

First album is more melodic and pop sounding. Second coming is more deep and moody. I prefer second coming.

All about personal choice I guess. Always got impression squire wanted them to be led zep and brown wanted funkadelic.

 

[BlueMoonRisin’]

All about personal choice I guess. Always got impression squire wanted them to be led zep and brown wanted funkadelic.

Don't get me wrong mate. First album is excellent and I have 2 CDs of it. It's just that prefer 2nd album. Tears is my favourite Roses track

 

[malg]

Don't get me wrong mate. First album is excellent and I have 2 CDs of it. It's just that prefer 2nd album. Tears is my favourite Roses track

Bang on for me, I always preferred the 2nd album.

 

[shackattack]

Don't get me wrong mate. First album is excellent and I have 2 CDs of it. It's just that prefer 2nd album. Tears is my favourite Roses track

I bought first album straight away from Woolworths of all places. Took me few years to buy second coming so maybe my judgement is clouded by sentiment. Just finished reading book on them - war and peace by Simon Spence. Interesting read.