Another new Brexit thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ric
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I rejoined Momentum this morning and as much as I think we should leave, any Labour MP that votes for a deal that removes workers rights is quite rightly finished.

I have posted that Brexit was never really just about Brexit it was also about the destruction of the Labour party and the chance for permanent rule for the Tories. A back door to a one party state, a state free to become the Singapore on Thames neo-liberal dreamland of the hard right.

Workers rights are not being taken away Rascal.

All week some have said they will be but no, the deal comes back and they are still there.

Look the MP's voting with the government wont give a fuck as they have no time for Corbyn or momentum and i dont blame them.

Who the fuck is Lansman to be threatening democratically elected MP's?
 
Agree with most of that but you can include the people in that equation -when the story of Brexit is retold to future generations, Chapter 2 will begin with ' Boris made himself comfortable in his favourite chair as the rain lashed against his cottage window, he drew a piece of parchment from his old Bullington notebook and began with the words 'reason to remain'

Youré right he has played everybody like a cheap fiddle but he has also had to continually reposition himself multiple times as the playing field has been turned upside down from within and without and from a strategical point of view he should get credit for that; although he really does owe Jezza a large one next time he sees him at the HOC bar.

Politicians squirm, have multiple faces and change with the weather to suit whatever situation they face.

Its hardly news but he did what he said he would do and the people, the electorate can see that.
 
No deal is not dead.

This agreement just kicks the can down the road until Dec 2020 when there will be another pinch point. FTA - Unlikely, Extension ? Crash out with no deal ?

This is why the ERG are happy to support.
 
Checks done at the ports of entry was also foretold was it not?

Bless you all upset at the sellout of the unionists given the way you have talked about them for 3 years.

Anyway dids, cant be arsed arguing with you any longer on this as it looks like the end game really is in sight and well, you wont get what you wanted or said you would.
Who says I’m upset? As I’ve said before it should be up to NI as to whether this is acceptable either by a referendum or by agreement by a majority of MPs there. It’s a new status that’s being imposed on them otherwise.
If this goes through I’ll stick with my prediction that Scotland will follow NI out of the UK.
 
So long as it gets voted through tomorrow you can think what you like, it matters not one jot but we wont agree on that, ever.

That’s true, it’s funny that we argue so much about it but then both of us are happy for it to be voted through.
 
It seems to me that this situation is actually very very simple. I've had my "road to Damascus" moment, but others seem to be struggling with it, so let me explain where I am coming from.

1. We had a referendum which I am sure everyone will agree, despite all our preferences, reservations, objections or what-have-you's, was positioned as a, once-in-life-time binary vote on whether we should stay in, or Leave. And also there was a universal commitment from all involved that the result would be respected.

2. Realising what a cluster-fuck this was, I chose to ignore this and argued passionately for a full reversal or a second referendum in order to get the result I'd have preferred. In hindsight, this was wrong. The result must be honoured. For two reasons, (a) because to not do so, would destroy all faith in democracy in this country and (b) because those who voted Leave will never let it drop anyway. We cannot move on, and start addressing all the problems in society - the very things that many people were driven to vote Leave over - until we move on and Leave.

3. There can no justification for rejecting a democratic referendum result. However, if there was to be one, then the only plausible objection might be that no-one voted to leave without a deal. That people were told there would be a deal. That the economy will be trashed without a deal. We now have a deal, so that objection is eiiminated and can no longer be valid.

Therefore the ONLY sensible option, the only morally acceptable option, is now for MPs to vote to accept the deal. I think enough of them will realise this and it will be passed.
 
It seems to me that this situation is actually very very simple. I've had my "road to Damascus" moment, but others seem to be struggling with it, so let me explain where I am coming from.

1. We had a referendum which I am sure everyone will agree, despite all our preferences, reservations, objections or what-have-you's, was positioned as a, once-in-life-time binary vote on whether we should stay in, or Leave. And also there was a universal commitment from all involved that the result would be respected.

2. Realising what a cluster-fuck this was, I chose to ignore this and argued passionately for a full reversal or a second referendum in order to get the result I'd have preferred. In hindsight, this was wrong. The result must be honoured. For two reasons, (a) because to not do so, would destroy all faith in democracy in this country and (b) because those who voted Leave will never let it drop anyway. We cannot move on, and start addressing all the problems in society - the very things that many people were driven to vote Leave over - until we move on and Leave.

3. There can no justification from rejecting a democratic referendum result. However, if there was to be one, then the only plausible objection might be that no-one voted to leave without a deal. That people were told there would be a deal. That the economy will be trashed without a deal. We now have a deal, so that objection is eiiminated and can no longer be valid.

Therefore the ONLY sensible option, the only morally acceptable option, is now for MPs to vote to accept the deal. I think enough of them will realise this and it will be passed.

Always knew you was sensible but boy did we have some fucking rows over this ;-)
 
What's surprising is why NI would even want to be part of this shambles.
People on the ground don’t from a purely economical argument.
At parliamentary party level though it is an overridingly idealogical argument and The DUP, not without some basis, see this as a sellout, to get Britain out of the EU, not the UK.
 
Always knew you was sensible but boy did we have some fucking rows over this ;-)
Yes mate we did. I still think it's a complete clusterfuck of a decision, but sadly that's what we voted for. "Trust the electorate"? Do me a favour, they are cretins in large number. But they are cretins with a vote, so we are stuck with it.
 
Yes mate we did. I still think it's a complete clusterfuck of a decision, but sadly that's what we voted for. "Trust the electorate"? Do me a favour, they are cretins in large number. But they are cretins with a vote, so we are stuck with it.

We get asked to vote all the time and often, history proves we have made a huge fucking mistake but it is our mistake to make.

Even more so when Parliament gave their sovereignty over to us and said very clearly this is your decision and we will do whatever you instruct us to do.
 
Listening to sky news now and the woman on is from the Guardian i believe and not sure of her name but Labour policy, her thinking is absolutely negative and based on an acceptance that Labour can not win a GE.

For the official opposition to be a party of spoiling anything the government wants and not one of saying look, we will win a GE and make sure environmental protections are in place and workers rights etc is shameful.

Labour are finished as they currently stand.
 
We get asked to vote all the time and often, history proves we have made a huge fucking mistake but it is our mistake to make.

Even more so when Parliament gave their sovereignty over to us and said very clearly this is your decision and we will do whatever you instruct us to do.
The inconvenient truth.
 
Yes mate we did. I still think it's a complete clusterfuck of a decision, but sadly that's what we voted for. "Trust the electorate"? Do me a favour, they are cretins in large number. But they are cretins with a vote, so we are stuck with it.

And who says the working class have been abandoned by the two major parties?
 
Sam Giymah said on James O'Brien earlier that he got a call last night from Tory HQ asking him - as a Tory MP - what help will he need to be persuaded to vote for the deal....... they are that fucking out of touch
 
Continued proof of the old adage - Never Trust A Tory
Listened to RTÉ radio 1 this morning and a very good discussion that had Ben Lowry representing the Unionist view.
He spoke very well and quite moderately.

The thing about never trusting a Tory is, that it just seemed inevitable in the Republic that this would happen eventually. NI was strategic to UK governments at best and a nuisance even at that.
To Middle England, it has never been in doubt, that they would be willing to drop the place and be done with it.

That’s harsh. Particularly with the history of the last 100 years and however outdated an economical concept, the 6 counties are, Ulster Unionism does have a point as a whole, not just the DUP, when it says that the rules of consent are being changed at the first sign of them not having a majority in the Assembly.

The fact that there is no assembly at the moment and the UK government who they can no longer rely on, can impose a decision on them should it be like that in the future, means that lack of interest or inevitable betrayal that we down south are not surprised by, is starting to dawn on the Unionist community.
 
He is utterly fucking useless but deliberately so on brexit because he is a leaver.

McDonnell is a leaver.

Dont believe a fucking word they utter about no deal this or bad deal that.

They want out.
They also want in.
In power.
The possibility of that, even if they manage to stymie Johnson yet again, is now remote, to say the least.
If Corbyn thinks his incessant refusals to vote for anything, or to state which position he adopts, is gaining him
popularity, he's deluded. Labour have had obscure and constantly changing narratives on Brexit now for the past 3 years,
their modus operandi has been to attempt to humiliate Johnson, to object and introduce ridiculous stunts like the Benn act,
and Johnson has now completely done them over. If this deal isn't passed, it won't hurt Johnson, Corbyn could not possibly
refuse a GE, it will be called, and he will be well beaten imo.
If this happens, and labour don't get an electable leader immediately, they're gone for the forseeable.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top