Aguero injured

By the way, you really should have abandoned this "Look at De Bruyne's injuries in 18/19" strategy when we establised he didn't have surgery under Dr. Cugat.

Because now you're blaming him for the outcome of patients he didn't treat, which is even more stupid than thinking you know who should operate on our players.


Another swing and a miss.

Why do you always revert to the straw man? And constantly edit your posts after you initially post them to try and change your argument?
 

Another swing and a miss.

Why do you always revert to the straw man? And constantly edit your posts after your initially post them to try and change your argument?

You don't know what a straw man is, do you?

If you base your argument - Cugat is the wrong surgeon - on KDB's injury record and take the time to post it out in full several times, someone pointing out you're a fucking idiot because he didn't have surgery is not a strawman, it's literally attacking, and destroying, the core of your argument. You can't criticise someone's surgery when they don't fucking do one.


Here's my argument in full. You're a clown who doesn't have a clue about knee surgery and who is/isn't a good one. You jumped in spewing bollocks because Sané made it through a game, and now when being asked to back up your completely baseless claims, you're just fucking about and trying to worm out of simply admitting you're clueless.
 
Lol. You're a sad little man. The edit function should be taken away from you after your constant misuse.

Learn to admit when you are wrong. You must be awful in person.
 
Lol. You're a sad little man. The edit function should be taken away from you after your constant misuse.

Learn to admit when you are wrong. You must be awful in person.

If you're going to complain about how people post, learn to use the fucking reply button.

Edit - We're all still waiting for you to tell us why Cugat is the wrong surgeon by the way.
 
Laporte had surgery and has looked fine since. Aguero has a meniscus injury and we don't know how he's doing yet. KDB didn't have surgery. Gundogan had a surgery and has been playing 50 games a season since.

So really the only player who had a bad outcome was Mendy, who did his right ACL, and has had issues in the opposite knee since.

Laporte had multiple set backs

I already said KDB didn't have surgery. He had treatment by the same doctor

I didn't mention Gundogan

You're either incredibly thick, and/or a pathological liar with an insane ego. I'm tipping a bit of both. Only such a person would be constantly editing their arguments after they make a post.
 
giphy.gif
 
Laporte had multiple set backs

I already said KDB didn't have surgery. He had treatment by the same doctor

I didn't mention Gundogan

You're either incredibly thick, and/or a pathological liar with an insane ego. I'm tipping a bit of both. Only such a person would be constantly editing their arguments after they make a post.

No of course you didn't mention Gundogan, why bring up a successful surgery when discussing if Cugat is a good surgeon?

And by the way, Laporte has not had "multiple set backs." Unless coronavirus is a set back? He had one little muscle niggle which as we already discussed is to be expected when you have to come back and play.

Now I'll once more ask you to explain why Cugat is the wrong surgeon and you know better than City.

Maybe you'll answer this time.
 
Oh lord. He just keeps on going. Ego driven maniac whose life revolves around having the last say on everything, no matter how wrong he is.

Go ahead, little man. You can have it.

P.S. I don't reply directly to your posts because they're generally trash, and duly treated as such.
 

I know, I know, its a petty argument, Im just so bored of people who haven't got a fucking clue, deciding they know so much better than the club on everything and proclaiming City are doing something wrong with absolutely nothing to back it up.

Normally I would ignore it but I'm just watching the everton game so I have time to waste trying to force him to answer the question.
 
I know, I know, its a petty argument, Im just so bored of people who haven't got a fucking clue, deciding they know so much better than the club on everything and proclaiming City are doing something wrong with absolutely nothing to back it up.

Normally I would ignore it but I'm just watching the everton game so I have time to waste trying to force him to answer the question.

Here's my very last post on the topic, since I know you'll likely keep on going forever to try and be 'right'.

Please, learn how to debate people and argue your point in a calm, composed, rationale manner. We're all fans of the same club here. We only want what's best for the team. In this instance, I'm sick of our players having constant setbacks after seeing this doctor, because I want them on the pitch. Whether Cugat is indeed responsible here is debatable, sure, but there is a clear trend that has emerged.

When you're presented with facts (KDB injury history), try not to twist and turn them because your initial argument/points were way off and you're trying to save face. It's not needed. Your initial and subsequent claims were incorrect as I pointed out to you, but instead of simply admitting to it, you doubled down. I've now seen you do this numerous times across the forum.

People that don't agree with you aren't your enemy, they're not 'fucking clowns' - they have a different viewpoint, that's it.
 
Here's my very last post on the topic, since I know you'll likely keep on going forever to try and be 'right'.

Please, learn how to debate people and argue your point in a calm, composed, rationale manner. We're all fans of the same club here. We only want what's best for the team. In this instance, I'm sick of our players having constant setbacks after seeing this doctor, because I want them on the pitch. Whether Cugat is indeed responsible here is debatable, sure, but there is a clear trend that has emerged.

When you're presented with facts (KDB injury history), try not to twist and turn them because your initial argument/points were way off and you're trying to save face. It's not needed. Your initial and subsequent claims were incorrect as I pointed out to you, but instead of simply admitting to it, you doubled down. I've now seen you do this numerous times across the forum.

People that don't agree with you aren't your enemy, they're not 'fucking clowns' - they have a different viewpoint, that's it.

Here's the problem.

You aren't looking for a debate. When someone wades into a thread thinking they know better than City, than every club in Spain, than all the worldwide elite athletes that fly from all over the world to go to Cugat's practice every week, they aren't looking for a debate.

When someone knows that what they're saying is so fucking baseless, and they have nothing to back it up whatsoever, actually engaging in a conversation is impossible. The arrogance to assume you, a fucking nobody with no experience in the field, know better is insurmountable.

KDB's injury history is not a fact that proves Cugat is a bad surgeon, not just because he didn't get fucking surgery! He went to Barcelona to undergo tests to see if he needed surgery, he didn't and flew home. So that you're trying to use that in an attempt to prove Cugat is shit shows you're beyond help. I did think he got surgery and admitted i was wrong, unlike you, who after going on a lecture about "facts" then claimed you always knew he hadn't had surgery despite posting earlier that he had, and had to back track when I quoted your lie back to you.

If you were really interested in facts, you'd have mentioned things like Christian Fink, Sané's surgeon, has also operated on Corentin Tolisso, a player who Bayern fans will tell you never recovered from it. He also operated half a dozen times on Marco Reus who keeps getting reinjured. Because that just happens sometimes.

He's also done 5 surgeries on Kingsley Coman, who keeps rupturing the same ligaments.

Turns out there isn't a mythical super-surgeon in Innsbruck who has a perfect record and all his patients come back better than ever, and if there was, I can guarantee City would be using him.




The reason I said you're a fucking clown is not because you disagree with me, but because you jumped in, said something obviously stupid, and then dodged every attempt to get you to answer the simple question put to you by multiple users - "Who are you to question Cugat's surgical ability?".

A question you still haven't answered because we all know the answer is you don't have a clue.

And that is the end of the conversation.
 
I know, I know, its a petty argument, Im just so bored of people who haven't got a fucking clue, deciding they know so much better than the club on everything and proclaiming City are doing something wrong with absolutely nothing to back it up.

Normally I would ignore it but I'm just watching the everton game so I have time to waste trying to force him to answer the question.
I think the club get more right than they get wrong, now if you are talking about old City, when Swales was chairman then fans would have point but not now its ridiculous to suggest that Cugat is a poor surgeon.
 
Love Aguero should go down as one of the all time great strikers to have played in England, but he is prone to lengthy periods out and has been the whole time he has been with out(which makes his goal tally even more impressive)and having only one other striker is always a risk, I hope Delap is able to step it up, but its alot to ask a 17 year old.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top