Penalty Taker

Who should take penalties if Haaland is not on the pitch?


  • Total voters
    387
Anyone but Sterling, you knew he was going to miss last night. He can't actually shoot properly its rather perplexing.
Gundogan is he is on the pitch for me, not because he is that good at them (no one in our team is) but he is German.
 
He is an awful penalty taker and getting worse at it, I know he has scored a lot of pens but it just disguises a bit of a hit and hope affair.

Tevez was similar

Mario or Yaya, you just never thought they would ever miss, the difference is the chill calm demeanour they exhibit and cooly slotting the ball home, side-footed right in the corners, no keeper is stopping those.

Sterling should never take a pen again, why he keeps grabbing the ball is anybody's guess, he is either brave or dumb.
Watching Sterling heaving down deep breaths, before he took it, was all I needed to see. It was always going to be over or under hit. Assuming Pep didn’t decree it - KDB has to take some responsibility for not taking the ball off him - I can’t believe Sterling was designated penalty taker at that point in the game.

I can only assume he wanted it to boost his confidence... oops. I wouldn’t mind but he hadn’t been on the pitch all that long, and hadn’t done enough to earn the opportunity for a goal.
 
He is an awful penalty taker and getting worse at it, I know he has scored a lot of pens but it just disguises a bit of a hit and hope affair.

Tevez was similar

Mario or Yaya, you just never thought they would ever miss, the difference is the chill calm demeanour they exhibit and cooly slotting the ball home, side-footed right in the corners, no keeper is stopping those.

Sterling should never take a pen again, why he keeps grabbing the ball is anybody's guess, he is either brave or dumb.
I mean, Aguero’s career penalty conversion rate is 80%.

Balotelli’s is 86%.

I’d hardly suggest that Aguero is an awful penalty taker as it’s not true.
 
Watching Sterling heaving down deep breaths, before he took it, was all I needed to see. It was always going to be over or under hit. Assuming Pep didn’t decree it - KDB has to take some responsibility for not taking the ball off him - I can’t believe Sterling was designated penalty taker at that point in the game.

I can only assume he wanted it to boost his confidence... oops. I wouldn’t mind but he hadn’t been on the pitch all that long, and hadn’t done enough to earn the opportunity for a goal.
heaving down deep breaths, fucking hell who actually talks like that, do you work for the sun ?
 
I mean, Aguero’s career penalty conversion rate is 80%.

Balotelli’s is 86%.

I’d hardly suggest that Aguero is an awful penalty taker as it’s not true.
Again you are just looking at that stat and not using your eyes, I did try to explain in my post.

Aguero fills you with no confidence as he steps up and that is getting worse season on season, he has scored a lot of scruffy badly taken penalties but they still go down as converted in your stat.

What was Mario's for City, this is the period I only really care about?

He didn't miss for us and I believe he has missed a few since he left us dragging his stat downwards but that wasn't really the point.

Who would you slap your life savings on to score a penalty in blue in their prime playing for City?

Mario, Yaya = no doubt

Aguero, Tevez = very risky

Sterling = not a fucking chance
 
What annoys me is when managers say you can’t practice penalties! You can train yourself to hit the ball correctly in the bottom corner with pace if you practice enough it will make it easier when you take a penalty in a pressure situation.
 
That horrible little weasel at the swamp has scored 35 of his 38 penalties a success ratio of 92%. Ibrahimovic has 87% and the fake Ronaldo 84% whilst Messi is down at 77%.

Sergio is at 78%, Kevin at 80%, Sterling 40%, Gundogan 90% and Mahrez 62.5%.

It is obvious, to even the most stupid, that Mahrez and Sterling should never take a penalty during normal time ever again.

In Sterling's case I would not even nominate him for one in a penalty shoot out. The fact he is so bad at beating the keeper from 12 yards when under no pressure from a defender shows just why he is such a poor finisher during normal play.
 
heaving down deep breaths, fucking hell who actually talks like that, do you work for the sun ?
Sorry to the word police - I’ll tone down my metaphors for future posts on heavy breathing.

My point being, as the previous poster stated, the likes of Balotelli and Yaya (reliable penalty takers quoted) don’t stand there taking deep breaths in order to compose themselves. If you’re having to do that, leave it to someone else.

It’s not even as though he’d just made a lung busting run seconds before. The game had stopped while VAR checked it and everyone got set.
 
If Sergio is on I would prefer him to take the pens, I know he has missed some but he has also scored a lot and he will step up with so much confidence and no self doubt about penalties he has missed in the past.
I would like to see Foden given a chance as well, he is a great finisher, has so much self confidence and his role is growing every week in the team, he has pushed Mahrez off in-swinging corners and is taking free kicks that are crossed into the box, assist for Stones goal vs United in the semi final last week.
 
As long as he can strike the ball.....Should always be the most composed player on the pitch.For me that's either Eddie or,more conventionally,Gundogan.

I also suspect Cancelo could be a good choice.
 
It really could have come back to haunt us last night if Ederson had his pen saved and Brighton break down field to roll it into an empty net!!
In theory, as long as you inform the referee, at the point the game stops for the award of the penalty, Kyle Walker (if on the field) could put on a pre printed goalkeeper shirt and Ederson an out field shirt, and for the duration until the ball next going dead, i.e. immediately if we score or the next time the ball leaves the field, their positions are changed. Once the ball is dead, they change their shirts again and the game resumes as normal. All perfectly legal although unusual I admit.
 
I don't even think that Kev takes a great penalty to be honest. Never fills me with total confidence and if the keeper guesses right he'd probably save it as he never hits them with great power. I've never seen Rodri take a pen so woould probably opt for Gundog. Wouldn't mind seeing Eddie take one though as it would probably upset a few people and we'd get accused of being disrespectful agaiin.
 
In theory, as long as you inform the referee, at the point the game stops for the award of the penalty, Kyle Walker (if on the field) could put on a pre printed goalkeeper shirt and Ederson an out field shirt, and for the duration until the ball next going dead, i.e. immediately if we score or the next time the ball leaves the field, their positions are changed. Once the ball is dead, they change their shirts again and the game resumes as normal. All perfectly legal although unusual I admit.
Did not know that..thank you for the information, a very useful post..it does assume Ederson can deliver..mind you he would shoot like Franny..can you imagine the press going beserk over that scenario !!!
 
I believe only 5 penalties in 3 years have been missed without a touch from the keeper or woodwork, 3 of them belong to City. Some going that.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top