Who are the good pundits?

[Keeper!]

Souness, Keane and a rapidly incoming Nedum, that guy is going places, class act.

 

[Lauz9888]

Emma Hayes.

Annoying cockney voice and somerimes misspeaks but really interesting manager's perspective. Obviously does her research and understands the little tactical tweaks. Actually adds to your understanding of the game, rather than just describing what's happening she tells you why.

 

[Keeper!]

The whole punditry system needs a shake up..

You have Neville and Carragher regularly commentating on the rags and dippers games, openly expressing their bias, you're even subjected to Carragher cheering when the dippers score.

The guy is supposed to be impartial ffs, it's astonishing he's still employed by SKY to be honest..

It's bad enough having to put up with Tyler gushing all over the shop when it comes to anything rag or dipper related.

Neville uses the mic as a platform to advise who the rags should buy next, that's when he's not inciting fans to break into stadia to demonstrate against owners who have pumped a £billion into said club..

Over on BT you have Ferdinand, Scholes and Macmanaman who openly want to see the most successful English team of the last decade lose, especially when it's champions league night.

These 3 are usually anchored by Humphreys who is another grade A ****..!

Commentators and co- commentators are there for one thing and one thing only to fkin commentate..

Bobby this, Trent that, Mo the other seems to have taken the place of MACHADA..., ROOOONNNNEEEYYY and MARSHALLL,....YEESSS!

Unfortunately, it looks like we are going to have to put up with what we currently have for a bit longer as they all seem to have their feet well and truly ensconced under the table where the PL / CL is concerned..

I personally like listening to the guy who does the Scottish football, Crocker ?

Regarding pundits, Potter (Brighton) and Parker (Bournemouth) would be good to hear from.

Both are modern thinking managers who don't appear to have an agenda and one would think, would offer good, intelligent and thoughtful insight for the watching public..

FWIW, I don't mind Souness, Keane and Hargreaves too, the rest of the usual suspects are consistently beyond crap..!

I dislike Gary Neville the rag very much but he is a very decent and fair pundit.

It must destroy him inside when he watches us and see's how well our club is run from top to bottom, but he does credit us.

Carragher is bitter but what do you expect from Bootle's finest.

 

[HalfwayUpTheKippax]

Coisty is really good. Love listening to Nevin too.
Believe it or not, Keane is growing on me (did I just say that?? I need to lie down)
:)

Keane is obviously an utter twat but I love hearing him slag off the rags. It’s almost as therapeutic as it is enjoyable

 

[HalfwayUpTheKippax]

My favourites are
1. Nevin - totally unbiased, focussed on football, not a cock
2. Ned - intelligent, articulate and needs to be given much greater prominence (should take over from turncoat twat Hinchcliffe)
3. Souness - says what he thinks, not what he’s told
4. Joe Cole - I have been pleasantly surprised and impressed with him

 

[Cityfan]

Nevin lose all credibility by listing its in front of the kop as a reason not to give a pen at anfield

I wasn't aware of the occasion.
As a matter of interest did he list it as a reason why a penalty should not be given or as a reason why a penalty was not given?

 

[Mancity1980]

Couldn't stand Robbie Savage as a player but he's one of the better pundits out there, I think

He’s a bit funny but his analysis is shocking, he compensates for his lack of brain cells with humour.

 

[Mancity1980]

Coisty is really good. Love listening to Nevin too.
Believe it or not, Keane is growing on me (did I just say that?? I need to lie down)
:)

Don’t tell Erling’s dad…:)

 

[Saddleworth2]

Roy Kent the Chelsea hardman.

 

[Bonzo Nododo]

I wasn't aware of the occasion.
As a matter of interest did he list it as a reasonwhy a penalty should not be given or as a reason why a penalty was not given?

You won't find it in any rule book but penalties are not awarded as a matter of fact of life to away teams in front of the Kop or the Stretford End.
Not many awarded at the other end either.

 

[JRockBlues]

Craig Burley isn't too bad usually.. In fact ESPN is fairly decent coverage all round and seem to be using Nedum the most of any broadcaster.

 

[Seedy Ron]

Ive always found Danny mills fairly logical and unbiased

 

[Spurs quarter 69]

You won't find it in any rule book but penalties are not awarded as a matter of fact of life to away teams in front of the Kop or the Stretford End.
Not many awarded at the other end either.

Uniteds boys deserted the Stretford End for K stand 30 years ago at least, why does it still get referenced as a partisan home end. In its hay day it was only a biggish paddock with an inflated reputation .

 

[Seedy Ron]

I think I've managed a team of them. A few out of position but beggars can't be choosers.

1 Shay Given

2 Michael Dawson 4 Graeme Souness 3 Nedum Onuha

6 Owen Hargreaves 5 Paul Lake

7 Pat Nevin 8 Tim Sherwood 11 Joe Cole

9 Ally McCoist 10 Ian Wright

All of these seem fair as far as I can see but are outnumbered by about 5 to 1 by the shite/biased pundits.

 

[Bonzo Nododo]

Uniteds boys deserted the Stretford End for K stand 30 years ago at least, why does it still get referenced as a partisan home end. In its hay day it was only a biggish paddock with an inflated reputation .

Well l for one don't take much notice of exactly where these partisanfans go on their tourist trips. They are all twats wherever they sit.
I thought K stand is the one from which they hurl coins, darts, batteries etc at away fans. If so it's a bit remote from the ref.

 

[knuckles]

I think I've managed a team of them. A few out of position but beggars can't be choosers.

1 Shay Given

2 Michael Dawson 4 Graeme Souness 3 Nedum Onuha

6 Owen Hargreaves 5 Paul Lake

7 Pat Nevin 8 Tim Sherwood 11 Joe Cole

9 Ally McCoist 10 Ian Wright

All of these seem fair as far as I can see but are outnumbered by about 5 to 1 by the shite/biased pundits.

Replace Ian Wright with Shaun Goater and that would be my 'team'!

 

[tonea2003]

must admit i like martin keown, makes me laugh with some of his comments

yesterday for instance when he said the forest keeper "threw one in" when attempting his clearance for Leicester's goal

and laura woods, not sure why though........

 

[LongsightM13]

must admit i like martin keown, makes me laugh with some of his comments

yesterday for instance when he said the forest keeper "threw one in" when attempting his clearance for Leicester's goal

and laura woods, not sure why though........

Keown going on about KDB having “paintbrushes for feet” is the new “jumpers for goalposts” isn’t it? Marvellous…

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

City Xtra need to be taken off the list, apparently. :-(

 

[hello]

I wasn't aware of the occasion.
As a matter of interest did he list it as a reason why a penalty should not be given or as a reason why a penalty was not given?

He listed 3 reasons why the Cardiff penalty wasn’t given including citing it was in front of the kop.