It's Quiet 17 - Glory Thread

4? Gomez and Tsimikas are 2 of their 5 and they're a big drop off from the main 3.
The point is not to debate the relative merits, it’s that they have four senior international CBs and even the lesser of those just signed a five year deal. So keeping four happy needn’t necessarily be impossible.
I think the Ake situation is purely related to a perfect storm of a weirdly timed World Cup and interest from the club where he started out, which itself is at least partly inspired by the fallout from external political factors.
In a normal year, I reckon Ake stays put quite happily, at least for another season or two
 
We don't need any players like Salisu. Waste of money! In any case, if we buy someone, he should be someone who can compete for the starting line-up!
That's a lazy piece, someone with no idea.

We will replace with a top quality CB, the more competition the better, it raises standards.
 
The point is not to debate the relative merits, it’s that they have four senior international CBs and even the lesser of those just signed a five year deal. So keeping four happy needn’t necessarily be impossible.
I think the Ake situation is purely related to a perfect storm of a weirdly timed World Cup and interest from the club where he started out, which itself is at least partly inspired by the fallout from external political factors.
In a normal year, I reckon Ake stays put quite happily, at least for another season or two
But Ake is a level above Matip, Gomes, Tsimikas and Konate so why would he want to be 4th choice, as is widely reported? I would imagine Ake would have been quite happy to stay, but playing regularly, at 27, must appeal and good luck to him, I say.

He has played 40 games for city in 2 seasons which is 10 more than Tsimikas and Gomez combined. I would argue that the reason the four 'senior internationals' have signed is two-fold. One is obviously the cash and 2, more importantly, Chelsea (or any other top level club) are not in for them.
Pep obviously prefers Laporte and Dias (even when it always looks, to me at least, that Stones and Dias look the best pairing) as his first choice and he always seems loath to keep someone in the team just because they've played well. That being said, he does seem to know what he is doing, so I am not criticising him.
 
But Ake is a level above Matip, Gomes, Tsimikas and Konate so why would he want to be 4th choice, as is widely reported? I would imagine Ake would have been quite happy to stay, but playing regularly, at 27, must appeal and good luck to him, I say.

He has played 40 games for city in 2 seasons which is 10 more than Tsimikas and Gomez combined. I would argue that the reason the four 'senior internationals' have signed is two-fold. One is obviously the cash and 2, more importantly, Chelsea (or any other top level club) are not in for them.
Pep obviously prefers Laporte and Dias (even when it always looks, to me at least, that Stones and Dias look the best pairing) as his first choice and he always seems loath to keep someone in the team just because they've played well. That being said, he does seem to know what he is doing, so I am not criticising him.
I really don't think Ake is a level above matip/konate, I'd say they are both comfortably better

Also, Gomez has been injured for nearly an entire year of the 2 years Ake has been at city and tsimikas has been at Liverpool for 1 year out of the two, so that's an extremely disingenuous comparison.

In fact, tsimikas (Liverpool's second choice left back) has had the same amount of minutes as Ake this season - around 1700.
 
Last edited:
Ake is not a level above matip/konate.

Also, Gomez has been injured for nearly an entire year of the 2 years Ake has been at city and tsimikas has been at Liverpool for 1 year out of the two, so that's an extremely disingenuous comparison.

In fact, tsimikas (Liverpool's second choice left back) has had the same amount of minutes as Ake this season - around 1700.
Tsimikas signed in August 2020 and made his debut in September of the same year, which I reckon is 2 seasons. Played 2 PL games that season which was the season Van Dyke was out, and 13 the next. I reckon that is 2 seasons ago.

Gomez made his debut in 2015 as an 18 year old and, in seven seasons, he has made 87 appearances.

Konate might turn out to be a fabulous player and you could be right about him, but then again.....

Matip is 30 and has played over 40 fewer PL games than Ake. I get you don't rate the lad, and I think he is only ever going to be 4th choice here, but why aren't Chelsea chasing any of those players?
 
Tsimikas signed in August 2020 and made his debut in September of the same year, which I reckon is 2 seasons. Played 2 PL games that season which was the season Van Dyke was out, and 13 the next. I reckon that is 2 seasons ago.

Gomez made his debut in 2015 as an 18 year old and, in seven seasons, he has made 87 appearances.

Konate might turn out to be a fabulous player and you could be right about him, but then again.....

Matip is 30 and has played over 40 fewer PL games than Ake. I get you don't rate the lad, and I think he is only ever going to be 4th choice here, but why aren't Chelsea chasing any of those players?
You're right about tsimikas, he has played for the dippers for 2 seasons, I thought he was only there for one season, my bad.

matip being 30 does not mean Ake is better than him.

Ake is comfortably better than Gomez and tsimikas, but konate and matip are miles ahead of him
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top