It's Quiet 17 - Glory Thread

alexmcity said:
Everyone is guessing about the future, apart from few well established facts related to death and taxes :)

But not all guesses are equally good or bad!

Guesses can be more and less informed, more and less grounded in facts, etc.

I think that Naylor's info about Brighton contains more truth than groundless speculation, so it's closer to 100% than to 1%. His record provides evidence for this, it's not a groundless guess.

Your generalisations are guesses too btw, and not very good in this case imo :)

Time will tell (that I'm right :) )
Click to expand...
Everyone is entitled to an opinion but doesn't mean you are correct in your opinion.
I will ask again if nobody knows the actual price that Tony Bloom & BHA want how can we be a million miles away from the asking price ????
I want facts not what people are surmising or what they've heard or read.

How are my generalisations as you put it guesses ??????

How many so called transfers do we see every season not just for City & how many actually happen

How do you know for certain thats what Naylor is posting is, from a source high enough up the food chain for it to be acurate, until this Cucurella saga I'd never heard of him.
 
Coatigan said:
It doesn't necessarily need to be that extreme, and it can still be true that nobody really knows, despite it not being entirely speculative rubbish.

If they are claiming the price Brighton would consider would 'start at' 50m, then even if it is something they have been told rather than guessed, that could still be 50m, could be 60 including Add-ons. If they have been told valuations are 20m apart, we might be offering 40m, not 30 which is a guess back from '50'.

It may or may not be speculative rubbish, but I think it is not unfair or wrong to say that nobody really knows.
Click to expand...

Nobody really *knows*. Agree!

But some people are closer to truth in their reports or gueses than other people. Common sense! It's silly to think that everybody makes equally good/bad gueses simply because they are, well, guesses. That's speculative garbage.

My guess is that journo Naylor is right that Brighton's asking price is 50m. The + is added to indicate they won't go much lower than 50m if at all. That's my guess. Time will tell whether it's close to truth or a bit silly (due to taking Naylor's words seriously).

I'll be happy to be wrong! It would be great to sign Cucu for 40m. But it won't happen, imo.
 
Fordyboy46 said:
Why does it take so long to come back with another bid?. Surely if 30m is rejected, can't we come back straight away with 40m plus add ons, then if that is rejected, 45m plus add ons etc etc. Could be done in minutes, unless it all boils down to the classic phrase of 'preparing a bid' pmsl
Click to expand...
Yep, that's exactly how it works.

 
Fordyboy46 said:
Why does it take so long to come back with another bid?. Surely if 30m is rejected, can't we come back straight away with 40m plus add ons, then if that is rejected, 45m plus add ons etc etc. Could be done in minutes, unless it all boils down to the classic phrase of 'preparing a bid' pmsl
Click to expand...

Fancy buying my house?
 
Fordyboy46 said:
Why does it take so long to come back with another bid?. Surely if 30m is rejected, can't we come back straight away with 40m plus add ons, then if that is rejected, 45m plus add ons etc etc. Could be done in minutes, unless it all boils down to the classic phrase of 'preparing a bid' pmsl
Click to expand...
PM me, I have some magic beans
 
Its all a dance, we have a price we are willing to pay but would happilly pay less if we can, likewise uf our valuation is too low for Brighton we will move on to the next target.
 
foggy1974 said:
Everyone is entitled to an opinion but doesn't mean you are correct in your opinion.
I will ask again if nobody knows the actual price that Tony Bloom & BHA want how can we be a million miles away from the asking price ????
I want facts not what people are surmising or what they've heard or read.

How are my generalisations as you put it guesses ??????

How many so called transfers do we see every season not just for City & how many actually happen

How do you know for certain thats what Naylor is posting is, from a source high enough up the food chain for it to be acurate, until this Cucurella saga I'd never heard of him.
Click to expand...
Don’t know about a million miles but pretty sure we were more than a million quid away or it wouldn’t have been rejected
 
Fordyboy46 said:
Why does it take so long to come back with another bid?. Surely if 30m is rejected, can't we come back straight away with 40m plus add ons, then if that is rejected, 45m plus add ons etc etc. Could be done in minutes, unless it all boils down to the classic phrase of 'preparing a bid' pmsl
Click to expand...
Looks like you’re a fan of “ art of negotiation “.
 
I wonder if Chelsea will come back in for Ake with a big offer when kounde turns them down for Barca
I can still see him leaving
Chelsea must be getting desperate now
 
Tb1981 said:
I wonder if Chelsea will come back in for Ake with a big offer when kounde turns them down for Barca
I can still see him leaving
Chelsea must be getting desperate now
Click to expand...
No as per reports they are going for Kimpembe . PSG want 50-60mil . Same price as kounde. Even we want 50 for ake
 
CityBluez said:
No as per reports they are going for Kimpembe . PSG want 50-60mil . Same price as kounde. Even we want 50 for ake
Click to expand...
Kimpembe is shite
I’m not really that sure anyone they are after is any good
Ake is ok
Koulibaly good but has played in Italy at a snails pace
Kounde I’m not really sure how good but maybe best of those three
 
Fordyboy46 said:
Why does it take so long to come back with another bid?. Surely if 30m is rejected, can't we come back straight away with 40m plus add ons, then if that is rejected, 45m plus add ons etc etc. Could be done in minutes, unless it all boils down to the classic phrase of 'preparing a bid' pmsl
Click to expand...
Let them sweat on it a bit. If they think we're serious about buying him, they'll be starting to scope out replacements, and speaking to agents about them. If we leave them for a few days, we know they'll start getting a bit more attached to those targets, and more likely to consider selling their player.
 
Kinkladze 1 said:
How is knowing the answer to your question going to change your day? One way or the other there might be a couple of million quid in it. What’s it matter?! Honestly the mither TH gets is ridiculous.
Click to expand...
He doesn't need to answer anything he doesn't want to. In fact if he doesn't want any mither at all he could just not post information on here, it's all his choice. I'm sure he doesn't need you to protect him.
 
Southampton apparently trying to get Edozie. I'm surprised that we're willing to sell him opposed to loaning him. Granted I haven't seen him play a ton, I remember being terribly impressed with him vs Leicester in the community shield last year.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top