19 | Julian Alvarez - 2022/23

Status
Not open for further replies.
Alvarez is great, great, great. One of the best young players in the world right now, and one of the best strikers in England.

But I feel, looking at this forum, that a lot of City fans have forgotten exactly how good Erling Haaland is, since it's been nearly two months since we had the pleasure of watching him at full fitness. Remember the hat-trick against United? Remember the volley vs Dortmund? The 4th goal vs Palace, opener against Brighton, etc. Alvarez is good, but he's not THAT good. No shame in being not quite as good as one of the best young strikers in the history of the game, though.

If you're asking whether he's up the pecking order on the wings, though, I would say maybe? But he's clearly better centrally. I'd like to see a 442 regardless, as I'm really not a fan of Jack or the current iteration of Mahrez, and I think Foden is way better centrally.
Yup, we are all dullards with severe memory problems.

Haaland who?

ffs
 
I'm of the opinion they are lucky to play football and get well paid for it, get out there and play and train as hard as required.

So let's hope you're wrong about his mental fatigue.
I think footballers are incredibly lucky to get paid as well as they do. But whereas big pay checks can pay to relieve some of the daily stresses that the rest of us face. They don't remove all stresses and their job is essentially to play better than other incredibly well paid footballers not all of whom will have had the amount of moving, WC and continuous season that he has had.
I am not saying these things will be afactor but I certainly would not be surprised if they were and we get a bit of mental tiredeness in the second half of this season
 
Man, signing Grealish was comfortably the worst decision we've made since the takeover. I have no clue what our (usually excellent) board were thinking. You're right, this would be great, but it would mean Pep admitting that Jack isn't good enough, which we would never allow.
He can rotate
 
Man, signing Grealish was comfortably the worst decision we've made since the takeover. I have no clue what our (usually excellent) board were thinking. You're right, this would be great, but it would mean Pep admitting that Jack isn't good enough, which we would never allow.
It would mean playing a completely different system to the one we play, clogging up the centre of the pitch, and giving up the control that our manger desires. Not sure what Grealish has to do with it. It's not like Pep has been breaking his back or the system to get him in the game.
 
Man, signing Grealish was comfortably the worst decision we've made since the takeover. I have no clue what our (usually excellent) board were thinking. You're right, this would be great, but it would mean Pep admitting that Jack isn't good enough, which we would never allow.
What do you mean wouldn't allow ? Pep wouldn't play him if he thought he wasn't tgood enough,
 
He knows the square root of fuck all does @MarsLlama
He pops up sporadically on threads to let us know how shit he thinks a player is then fucks off again.

We have a few posters on here who are post generators! If everyone agrees with everything on a forum it gets boring!

Example Say “Alvarez is fantastic player” you get yeah with one or two posts say “Alvarez be average and Messi makes him look good” you will have more interaction!
 
We have a few posters on here who are post generators! If everyone agrees with everything on a forum it gets boring!

Example Say “Alvarez is fantastic player” you get yeah with one or two posts say “Alvarez be average and Messi makes him look good” you will have more interaction!
Alvarez looks fantastic and everyone should be excited to see him develop under Pep.
What people shouldn’t be doing, unless they’re cunts obviously, is turn his great WC performances into a dig at Grealish or any other player. It’s proper sad behaviour.
 
We have a few posters on here who are post generators! If everyone agrees with everything on a forum it gets boring!

Example Say “Alvarez is fantastic player” you get yeah with one or two posts say “Alvarez be average and Messi makes him look good” you will have more interaction!
Yeah, you're right. IMHO we have a star on our hands. Not saying he's gonna be as good as Sergio, but he's gonna be a star. He's pretty damn good already.
 
We have a few posters on here who are post generators! If everyone agrees with everything on a forum it gets boring!

Example Say “Alvarez is fantastic player” you get yeah with one or two posts say “Alvarez be average and Messi makes him look good” you will have more interaction!
But how do you take an opinion seriously when it is completely unmovable, rigid and based on zero evidence?

How do you take the opinion seriously when you know that poster hates Jack Grealish and simply can't fathom the idea that he's good even though he's not scoring lots of goals?
 
But how do you take an opinion seriously when it is completely unmovable, rigid and based on zero evidence?

How do you take the opinion seriously when you know that poster hates Jack Grealish and simply can't fathom the idea that he's good even though he's not scoring lots of goals?

Grealish as a player is in that very grey area where like me I see him contributing to the team and an asset! Others see him in what he puts out as in assists and goals and now we have players on the bench who could can have better stats if given the chance is where I can see other fans thinking and just let it go as there opinion and a valid one..
 
Alvarez looks fantastic and everyone should be excited to see him develop under Pep.
What people shouldn’t be doing, unless they’re cunts obviously, is turn his great WC performances into a dig at Grealish or any other player. It’s proper sad behaviour.
To add to this, the thesis itself about Grealish as our worst transfer ever is so one-sided! (to avoide more offensive take like narrow-minded or lame;)

JG was an answer for an honest need to make a move during summer 2021, especially since Kane's transfer started to look doubtful. We were in a need of attacking players, pursuing two for real, Jack had a great season at Villa, his cameos during Euro were exciting. He is Englishman, his popularity elevated up massively during the Euro. Still for us it should be seen as a great honour to attract best players from England, it is not as easy as it sounds now when You compete with so decorated clubs as Utd, Liverpool, Arsenal, Chelsea and so on, historically much more popular than City. We are slowly there, what many would have seen as impossible several years ago. City still need to expand its popularity, to pull attraction, to constantly grow. Grealish is perfect for this.

We do not like to hear this, but truth to be told - decisions are made in light of circumstances which exists atm of carring them out, nobody is a fairy.

Actual football aspect? He was of much better use for this team, than media or supporters of other clubs want You to believe it. He attracts opponents, has really great technique, but crucial part is he is able to hold the ball like not many others, run with it fast and close - to let other players and a team as a whole to fix their structure, sometimes catch a breathe. His goals and assists stats are so misleading as in reality he is much more involved in a game and positive result, than those numbers indicates. Last derby with Utd - zero goals, zero assists, yet absolutely brilliant performance.

Luckily enough - Pep knows football aspect better than anyone and my guess is he values Jack properly, much better than many of our own supporters, which is actually a shame in my book.

Grealish is not a flop, he made a lot for us and hes going to add even more.
 
I thought the Alvarez performance thread was getting a bit too focused on Alvarez and his wonderful World Cup campaign, I'm glad we can now get on with the real issue: is Jack Grealish worth £100m.

I always look at is £150 mil for Haaland and Grealish. No one would be moaning if we paid 100 mil for Haaland, so the fact we paid half his market value cancels out "overspending" on Grealish.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top