The matter that should be debated is whether it’s prudent to keep picking a player on the basis that he’ll “do alright” 95% of the time or if it’s the 5% that the focus should be on. You pick Rico Lewis, you know that at some point he’ll get isolated deep in our half, turn over the ball under pressure and it’ll then end up in our net. You have him in the team, it’s like starting on minus 1. Same goes for Gundogan for different reasons.
It isn’t a hate fest or anything even remotely similar, just an acknowledgment of something that happens nearly every time he plays. Not a bad footballer, but physically he’s not up to scratch