Referees’ Performances | 2024/2025

Darren Cann the Crystal Palace fan who was allowed to run the line for us against Palace as it was his last match now gets the cup final gig as no doubt this is his very last match. Nothing to see here.

He’s never declared himself a Crystal Palace fan. I doubt Norfolk is a hotbed of Palace fans. Even ones who played a few games for their youth team, 30 odd years ago.

It’s also quite common for officials to retire from on field officiating and carry on with VAR duties.
 
Anyone watching the Newcastle game.
Pawson is taking any excuse to give Newcastle a penalty. But we can’t get one for a blatant handball.
 
Darren Cann the Crystal Palace fan who was allowed to run the line for us against Palace as it was his last match now gets the cup final gig as no doubt this is his very last match. Nothing to see here.
Not necessarily a fan, but did play for them at youth level
 
He’s never declared himself a Crystal Palace fan. I doubt Norfolk is a hotbed of Palace fans. Even ones who played a few games for their youth team, 30 odd years ago.

It’s also quite common for officials to retire from on field officiating and carry on with VAR duties.
Quite common? It’s the main reason why VAR will never be got rid of a nice earner once they get too fat ( ex Simon Hooper ) for on field
 
Quite common? It’s the main reason why VAR will never be got rid of a nice earner once they get too fat ( ex Simon Hooper ) for on field

They are actually working towards specialised VARs, rather than just the same refs on their day off.

It’s two completely different skill sets and not suited to all. Anthony Taylor is never a VAR, by his own request. Mike Dean didn’t last long when he tried it after retiring from reffing.

But there’s no reason why an experienced official, recently retired, couldn’t make a good specialised VAR. Or AVAR in Cann’s case.
 
They are actually working towards specialised VARs, rather than just the same refs on their day off.

It’s two completely different skill sets and not suited to all. Anthony Taylor is never a VAR, by his own request. Mike Dean didn’t last long when he tried it after retiring from reffing.

But there’s no reason why an experienced official, recently retired, couldn’t make a good specialised VAR. Or AVAR in Cann’s case.
Imagine the job spec
Good knowledge of Laws of the Game
Good eyesight, correction allowed

Can’t think of anything else
 
They are actually working towards specialised VARs, rather than just the same refs on their day off.

It’s two completely different skill sets and not suited to all. Anthony Taylor is never a VAR, by his own request. Mike Dean didn’t last long when he tried it after retiring from reffing.

But there’s no reason why an experienced official, recently retired, couldn’t make a good specialised VAR. Or AVAR in Cann’s case.
I think the problem Mike Dean had was that when they 1st brought in var he said that no one watching from a caravan would make him change his mind.
 
I’m just wondering how the ref got the first two penalties he gave so wrong at Brighton. As a fan, you instinctively know if it’s a penalty or not. The Newcastle fans must have been laughing to themselves when he gave initially gave them.

Piss poor referee.
 
I’m just wondering how the ref got the first two penalties he gave so wrong at Brighton. As a fan, you instinctively know if it’s a penalty or not. The Newcastle fans must have been laughing to themselves when he gave initially gave them.

Piss poor referee.
Correct. He also gave the free kick that led to their actual penalty when Harvey Barnes dived. Absolutely abysmal.
 
I would be more worried about Attwell than the assistant VAR official. The guy is an absolute liability
Absolutely.
It would have been Chris Kavanagh but unfortunately for him the FA won’t appoint a Manchester FA ref to a final with a Manchester team…
 
I’m just wondering how the ref got the first two penalties he gave so wrong at Brighton. As a fan, you instinctively know if it’s a penalty or not. The Newcastle fans must have been laughing to themselves when he gave initially gave them.

Piss poor referee.

Did you call the first one as outside the box before you saw a replay?

Well done if you did. But it would put you in a minority of about one.
 
To be honest, no. I thought the referee, who was 5 yards away might have seen it. The assistant commentator had his doubts immediately and he was in the main stand.

If that had happened on Friday night I would definitely have seen it from SS3 though!
 
To be honest, no. I thought the referee, who was 5 yards away might have seen it. The assistant commentator had his doubts immediately and he was in the main stand.

If that had happened on Friday night I would definitely have seen it from SS3 though!

Mate, I watched all 20 replays, or however many they showed. And at full speed there’s no way on earth anybody could be sure either way, from any of the angles.

It was only when they slowed it right down and froze the screen at the point of contact that you could see it was just outside.

There’s plenty of opportunity to have a pop at referees. But that really wasn’t one of them, if you’re being fair minded.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top