Player of the season | Josko Gvardiol wins club award (p19)

POTS?


  • Total voters
    109
Pep has really struggled this season when it comes to finding the right balance. It's still not great at times but throughout it all Gvardiol has been solid. Some defensive lapses but in contrast to others a consistent performer at LB and CB and his versatility has helped enormously this season.

I don't think anyone else comes close.
 
I've been totting up the scores all season from the Man of the Match threads. 3 points for the player with the most votes for the game, 2 for second most, 1 for third most.

So far the top 10 (in order) are:

Gvardiol - 30 points
Savinho - 27
Kovacic - 24
Doku - 22
De Bruyne - 21
Grealish - 20
Lewis - 18
Nunes - 17
O'Reilly - 15
Haaland - 14
 
I've been totting up the scores all season from the Man of the Match threads. 3 points for the player with the most votes for the game, 2 for second most, 1 for third most.

So far the top 10 (in order) are:

Gvardiol - 30 points
Savinho - 27
Kovacic - 24
Doku - 22
De Bruyne - 21
Grealish - 20
Lewis - 18
Nunes - 17
O'Reilly - 15
Haaland - 14
Shows how far Foden’s form has deteriorated to not be on that list.

Footballer of the year last season but absolute tosh this one.
 
He has played extremely well in most games but also dropped some horrendous bollocks.

I just don’t think anybody has done enough this season.
Well we’ve got to have someone!!!
 
It can’t be Johnny this year EB :-)
That's who I voted for though because his name was there. I had already decided it was going to be someone else because I did not expect his name to be there!!

It's not my fault, it's the club who are encouraging me. This is only the long list though. Even I, in my admiration of him, know he won't make the short list but at least I was true to him!!! :-) ;-)
 
He has played extremely well in most games but also dropped some horrendous bollocks.

I just don’t think anybody has done enough this season.

Highest scoring PL defender with a few crucial ones as you say a few shonkey moments but he’s been our best defender by far and let’s face it our midfield and forwards have been very in and out so they can’t be counted apart from maybe Haaland so Josko for me.
 
Gvardiol
Kova
OReilly
B Silva

I'm that order, no-one else in the running really, Nunes has done decent in a foreign position.
Haaland scored 30 goals in 40 games with 4 assists. Putting Bernardo in there above him is a bold move.
 
Honestly - give it O’Reilly or Khusanov.

Both young lads who’ve been thrown into the cauldron and shown huge promise for the future. And frankly shown up much older much more senior and much better paid colleagues.

Shame Khusanov isn’t getting as many games now but it’s the business end of the season and the current defence is ‘clicking’. Next season he’s going to be essential.
 
No real stand out player.

Haaland will probably win it because he is Haaland.

Not having a pop at him.

He’s just very popular with the City fan base.
 
Haaland scored 30 goals in 40 games with 4 assists. Putting Bernardo in there above him is a bold move.

He has but i tend not to judge midfielders on goals and assists like i do with strikers whose job it is to do exactly that.

We have won plenty with and without a 'goal machine'

I wouldn't say Haaland has been great at keeping the ball moving and creating a tempo but why would he.

We seem have a nice little winning streak going without him. Pots would need to include someone who has contributed to this run in my opinion.
 
He has but i tend not to judge midfielders on goals and assists like i do with strikers whose job it is to do exactly that.

We have won plenty with and without a 'goal machine'

I wouldn't say Haaland has been great at keeping the ball moving and creating a tempo but why would he.

We seem have a nice little winning streak going without him. Pots would need to include someone who has contributed to this run in my opinion.
His goals were vital to us getting the great start (Southampton , West Ham, Brentford) which is just as important as the winning run we're on now. I'd have him 2nd on the list.
 
His goals were vital to us getting the great start (Southampton , West Ham, Brentford) which is just as important as the winning run we're on now. I'd have him 2nd on the list.

How do you know they were vital, we don't have a parallel universe to judge it on. He has played too poorly to often to be considered for me.
Note I put 4 players who have dug in during this important part of the season to get us CL. In a grinding season that's who I'm going for, those who have played well and busted a gut.
 
How do you know they were vital, we don't have a parallel universe to judge it on. He has played too poorly to often to be considered for me.
Note I put 4 players who have dug in during this important part of the season to get us CL. In a grinding season that's who I'm going for, those who have played well and busted a gut.
What? Are you saying that 3pts from the beginning of the season are worth less than 3pts now? Eh?
 
I've been totting up the scores all season from the Man of the Match threads. 3 points for the player with the most votes for the game, 2 for second most, 1 for third most.
I have been doing the same - I posted under another thread. Red is points based on the same system you used, and blue is a count of the number of times they have been in the top 3. The link to the post with a graph is below -
Someone (sorry forget who) suggested this and I thought it would be interesting. I'll update the stats for the prior match once we get close to the next match.

Still working on the best way to do this, but updated through AVL game.
View attachment 154382

The Red bar- How many points the player has received based on on 3 points for 1st, 2 for 2nd, and 1 for 3rd.

The Blue bar - How many times a player has made the top 3.

There have been a lot of recent games where there is only 1 or 2 votes between 3 and 4th place...and in one instance, 3 players split the vote for third place (which was all less than 1%).

Once the season is over, I may try and split this between regular season and competition games, as I think that would be interesting.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top