ninjamonkey
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 5 Jun 2009
- Messages
- 22,644
I didn't say they were poaching directly from us, I said they're poaching all the players we let go early from other clubs.They are hardly poaching.
Palmer is the only youngster that went directly.
Delap, Lavia , Tosin and Sancho (possibly) all arrived from other clubs.
I'm surprised other clubs aren't following their example.
I read somewhere that 14 PL clubs had one of our ex players last season ( or possibly the season before)
Lavia is a cracking player, a fit Lavia would have been a perfect Rodri backup for us. hes played fairly well for them when he's been fit he's just had a John stones level of injuries. His talent cant be denied but he has to be available more often to justify his cost.I'm not sure it could be categorised as the best decision, perhaps more so the least worst.
They've spent an absolute fortune on average players, and the only decent player they've got came from City.
Lavia has been injured for a lot of the season, but has hardly been stand out when he has played.
Palmer has been a great signing for them, but I doubt anyone would argue that he's not a top player.
Palmer aside, I don't think any of their other ex-City players would even get on our bench, and I'd include Delap in that; I personally think he's a run of the mill English striker, that'll probably get them 15 premier league goals.
I personally think Delap is better than what you are saying but I can accept that opinion as fair as there's not enough evidence to accurately rate him yet. Even if he is a run of thr mill premier league striker though, they're in very short supply nowadays and lots of teams want and need them which makes him very appealing to many. A 15 goal striker is a dream for most teams and would make a huge difference, there's only 6 players who netted more goals this past season.