supercity88
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 9 Aug 2009
- Messages
- 13,823
In fairness, he’ll be judged because he’s taking loads of game time and producing nothing of note. He’s putting in solid but sadly unproductive performances. He’s simply not contributing the numbers. And whether it’s his fault or not, he’s our record signing and only signing for this season. He will be judged differently. Other players will play worse, but have money in the bank. Grealish hasn’t.
He seems a player who it’s deemed stupid to question. Well, let’s be frank, he’s been totally underwhelming and people are getting frustrated. I don’t think it’s unfair to start asking questions of him now.
I hear the argument about Mahrez, Gundogan or Rodri making a slow start. Which again is fair but easily and rightly scrutinised. Mahrez was in double figures for both goals and assists in his first season. Rodri wasn’t this Rodri but he was still a very solid player. Gundogan was frustrating but we’d seen moments of real class in games like when he tore Barcelona to shreds. We’d also seen him be one of the very best midfielders in the World at BVB.
Grealish came with huge questions to be answered. And for many, he’s left more questions so far and any answers we’ve got, have not been positive..
I’ve a group of City supporting mates who’ve all played the game for years, everyone of them at Wembley in 99.. Not one was convinced he was the right signing and are certainly less convinced after his performances to date.
I don't know what people are expecting of Jack. He's never been prolific. We're we expecting him to come in and score 20 goals a season and get 20 assists? He's somewhere between De Bruyne and Bernardo for me. Wants the ball to feet, likes to drive forwards with it and has the ability to craft chances for others and create space for them.
The main expectation I had of his arrival, was for an impact on the amount of space our other players would have as a result. But that's not been the case. He would often have two men on him, which in our team would mean space for De Bruyne/Foden etc who would thrive on it.
I'd love to see him play more centrally in the no8 role. I think that's where we'd get the best out of him. He's got the energy to go box to box. He's got the touch and control and pace and skill to drive the ball forwards and he would do a better job in there in my opinion. Pep clearly feels he's better learning the system out wide for now, where there's probably less risk from a defensive perspective. But he's not the first to struggle to adapt initially. I wanted us to sign him. I'm therefore hopeful and positive he'll be a great player for us. He just needs that one moment that a lot of the players have had to settle him down.
Mahrez was the boo boy and then just went to another level particularly in the CL. Won us games on his own. If Grealish plays shit for 90 minutes but pops up with a winner in Madrid he'll go up another level from the confidence boost.