10 | Jack Grealish - 2024/25

If opponents were given choice among Grealish or Doku they would happily choose Grealish bcoz they know he won’t do shit. Will keep all the ball outside box win free kicks outside the box hit first man while attempting cross.Teams are okay with us HAVING CONTROL and do fuckall with that CONTROL. We are probably the only team that prioritises CONTROL and WINNING FREE KICKS over Goals assists
This is the kind of post that makes me feel, at times, that we have the strangest fanbase in football.
You do realise that our style of play comes from the manager, and that style of play has delivered the most successful team of the decade?
There is a place for control, and a place for chaos. A top-class squad has players with a blend of strengths and abilities.
 
If opponents were given choice among Grealish or Doku they would happily choose Grealish bcoz they know he won’t do shit. Will keep all the ball outside box win free kicks outside the box hit first man while attempting cross.Teams are okay with us HAVING CONTROL and do fuckall with that CONTROL. We are probably the only team that prioritises CONTROL and WINNING FREE KICKS over Goals assists
But we did manage to do something with control in the Treble year - didn't we? - and in those incredible performances v Madrid, Bayern, Liverpool etc. Where control and tempo were our weapon, Grealish on or not.
Again more revisionism to support a position. At least you haven't invented player positions and ignored injuries like NM, to support an argument.
Although - a player doing what you said above? Or a headless chicken offering nothing defensively or in support and often being dispossessed, on the off chance of a trickling under hit cross.? Hmmm
 
This is the kind of post that makes me feel, at times, that we have the strangest fanbase in football.
You do realise that our style of play comes from the manager, and that style of play has delivered the most successful team of the decade?
There is a place for control, and a place for chaos. A top-class squad has players with a blend of strengths and abilities.
I think there are two types of control…

One is the control of the ball to create goal scoring opportunities and put the opposition on the defensive in an “attack vs defence” type situation.

The other is a “we have the ball, so you can’t score” type of control that is currently the pervasive type…yet we are leaking goals like a sieve as soon as we turn it over!!

Possession for possessions stake is where we appear to be, because we are pedestrian in our attacks and 70% possession isn’t making any difference to the REAL STAT of Goals For vs Goals Against!! We are +4, which is a joke compared to where we usually are.
 
Last edited:
Hmm so Grealish is being blamed for this poor run of form, is he?
Or is he being blamed for not turning games around when we're not winning?

Because last time I checked, there were 9 other outfield players who haven't exactly been playing well. Why is it "expected" of Grealish to turn defeats into wins when none of his teammates seem capable either and haven't for the past couple of months. Last time I saw Grealish put in a good performance was when he was being played in the middle, the position he prefers and excels in, and we commanded a fine 3-0 victory against a very strong Nottingham Forest side, in which Grealish was instrumental.

But no, it's the "He cost £100m, so he should have scored 100 million goals!" crowd. He does exactly what is expected of him to do out on the left, and I don't recall many times he didn't do precisely what he's being told to do. He creates chances for others, who then fluff their lines and it's Jack's fault. He tries a shot himself and misses and Jack is "useless in front of goal". Some people just love to hate the guy when he is no worse than quite a number at the club, yet he gets it in the neck all the time.

I think a lot of people will be very sad to see Grealish leave the club; they'll have lost their scapegoat.
 
I think there are two types of control…

One is the control of the ball to create goal scoring opportunities and put the opposition on the defensive in an “attack vs defence” type situation.

The other is a “we have the ball, so you can’t score” type of control that is currently the pervasive type…yet we are leaking goals like a sieve as soon as we turn it over!!

Possession for possessions stake is where we appear to be, because we are pedestrian in our attacks and 70% possession isn’t making any difference to the REAL STAT of Goals For va Goals Against!! We are +4, which is a joke compared to where we usually are.
We are porous because we are missing in defensive midfield and central defence. When we have a fully fit squad, that level of possession has been the fulcrum of our success.
 
Hmm so Grealish is being blamed for this poor run of form, is he?
Or is he being blamed for not turning games around when we're not winning?

Because last time I checked, there were 9 other outfield players who haven't exactly been playing well. Why is it "expected" of Grealish to turn defeats into wins when none of his teammates seem capable either and haven't for the past couple of months. Last time I saw Grealish put in a good performance was when he was being played in the middle, the position he prefers and excels in, and we commanded a fine 3-0 victory against a very strong Nottingham Forest side, in which Grealish was instrumental.

But no, it's the "He cost £100m, so he should have scored 100 million goals!" crowd. He does exactly what is expected of him to do out on the left, and I don't recall many times he didn't do precisely what he's being told to do. He creates chances for others, who then fluff their lines and it's Jack's fault. He tries a shot himself and misses and Jack is "useless in front of goal". Some people just love to hate the guy when he is no worse than quite a number at the club, yet he gets it in the neck all the time.

I think a lot of people will be very sad to see Grealish leave the club; they'll have lost their scapegoat.
We have always had a section of fans who scapegoat players. It remains the only thing that I dislike about being a City fan and has been the case through the dark days and the bright ones.
 
Hmm so Grealish is being blamed for this poor run of form, is he?
Or is he being blamed for not turning games around when we're not winning?

Because last time I checked, there were 9 other outfield players who haven't exactly been playing well. Why is it "expected" of Grealish to turn defeats into wins when none of his teammates seem capable either and haven't for the past couple of months. Last time I saw Grealish put in a good performance was when he was being played in the middle, the position he prefers and excels in, and we commanded a fine 3-0 victory against a very strong Nottingham Forest side, in which Grealish was instrumental.

But no, it's the "He cost £100m, so he should have scored 100 million goals!" crowd. He does exactly what is expected of him to do out on the left, and I don't recall many times he didn't do precisely what he's being told to do. He creates chances for others, who then fluff their lines and it's Jack's fault. He tries a shot himself and misses and Jack is "useless in front of goal". Some people just love to hate the guy when he is no worse than quite a number at the club, yet he gets it in the neck all the time.

I think a lot of people will be very sad to see Grealish leave the club; they'll have lost their scapegoat.
I don’t think it’s too much to ask for our record signing and 3rd highest paid player at the club to turn games around for us. After all kdb, mahrez, aguero, David silva, Gundo, yaya, sterling etc had games where they did just that
 
Hmm so Grealish is being blamed for this poor run of form, is he?
Or is he being blamed for not turning games around when we're not winning?

Because last time I checked, there were 9 other outfield players who haven't exactly been playing well. Why is it "expected" of Grealish to turn defeats into wins when none of his teammates seem capable either and haven't for the past couple of months. Last time I saw Grealish put in a good performance was when he was being played in the middle, the position he prefers and excels in, and we commanded a fine 3-0 victory against a very strong Nottingham Forest side, in which Grealish was instrumental.

But no, it's the "He cost £100m, so he should have scored 100 million goals!" crowd. He does exactly what is expected of him to do out on the left, and I don't recall many times he didn't do precisely what he's being told to do. He creates chances for others, who then fluff their lines and it's Jack's fault. He tries a shot himself and misses and Jack is "useless in front of goal". Some people just love to hate the guy when he is no worse than quite a number at the club, yet he gets it in the neck all the time.

I think a lot of people will be very sad to see Grealish leave the club; they'll have lost their scapegoat.
I think the issue is he's done a complete disappearing act since the treble winning season. Did he contribute? Of course. But take away those six months and his City career has been very underwhelming; he hasn't scored in over a year. That's not good enough for a player in his position.

And the price tag is relevant. That's not Jack's fault, but he was the club's record purchase. Ultimately, from the club's business perspective, he's supposed to be our prized asset; for a season and a half he's produced, well, nothing at all. The expectation and excitement that came with his signing has proven unwarranted.

I've been his staunchest advocate in the past. If you dig deep enough you'll find me backing him up on several occasions; but he's unrecognisable from the player we saw at Villa and time is running out for him. You said people would be sad to see him leave; at this point, I don't think they'd even notice.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.