1978-79 | The self-implosion of Manchester City

And Phil Thompson explaining in hi post match interview that he was "sick as a parrot" because the ref had given a penalty when he, Thompson, had deliberately hacked O'hare down just outside. It did mean more even then.
I was trying to remember the name of the Liverpool defender who brought ohare down for the pen.i remember it was a very controversial decision at the time.the media were all over it.
A few seasons later I don't recall anyone other than City fans giving any attention to Alf grey ruling out Kevin Reeves header in the league cup semi final.maybe because it wasn't shown ' live ' iirc.
 
Allison said when looking back at his career that his biggest regret was coming back to City. Steve Daley said he signed a TEN year contract when he joined us and was totally deflated when the move proved so disastrous. The harder he tried the worse it got for him with the crowd expectation proving too much for him to overcome. He realised the only option for him was to move abroad and left for Seattle. Allison always said he agreed a fee for Daley of £600,000 with Wolves over the phone but then returned from holiday only to find Swales had gone and offered £1,437,500 which Wolves of course snatched his hand off at and never mentioned their previous negotiations with Allison !
I bet they banked that cheque with some speed !
 
I was told by the City surgeon at the time that Allison chose and negotiated to buy the player not Swales.
 
I was trying to remember the name of the Liverpool defender who brought ohare down for the pen.i remember it was a very controversial decision at the time.the media were all over it.
A few seasons later I don't recall anyone other than City fans giving any attention to Alf grey ruling out Kevin Reeves header in the league cup semi final.maybe because it wasn't shown ' live ' iirc.
Aha
Illegal jumping?
 
Aha
illegal jumping?
It was something very strange.
I can remember a pic in the paper next day of Reeves going up for the header for the disallowed goal..I couldn't see anything wrong with it.
All the Blues I've spoken to,over the years, who were at the game...not one could say why it was ruled out.
Your illegal jumping term ,in jest I know ,makes me think of Kevin Horlock red card at Bournemouth for...aggressive walking, the latter being the reason given by the ref for KH red card...still to this day don't know why Alf grey ruled out Reeves Header.........
 
The goalkeeper at the other end (who Clough later bought for a then world record for a GK) allowed a shot to squeeze under his body which should have been a routine save for an international GK. There again, I thought Shilton was very overrated and had serious shortcomings particularly a lack of height and mobility towards the middle and later parts of his career.
Interesting points you make 're Shilton.
I .as a kid,respected both Clemence and Shilton as the top 2 England keepers,but really really wanted Joe Corrigan to get picked,just because he played for City.i thought ...of the two ..,Shilton was the better keeper,but that was just based on what I saw on MOTD etc rather than live action....
I,m aware that Shilton was obsessed with making himself taller as a young keeper,and also that Clough said he was worth 10 pts a season ,or somethimg like that when they won the Old 1st Division title.

As far as Clemence is concerned,looking back he got a lot of accolades just because he was at Liverpool,he also got a lot protection from some excellent defensive units... over the years at Anfield...Phil Neal Thompson,Hansen Hughes.all excellent defenders of goal..and Liverpool did have that habit of passing the ball along the back four ,one to anothef,back to Clemence ,roll out to the fullback..repeat,esp on away games to run down the clock and numb the vitriol of the home crowd.....

On balance,I still think Shilton was the better keeper,...but i agree that shot he let in at Wembley v Poland was not his finest moment.
 
I was told by the City surgeon at the time that Allison chose and negotiated to buy the player not Swales.

No one disputes that Allison chose the players. But in Tony Book's autobiography, he definitely states that Swales negotiated the fees and I think that Tony was probably better placed than anyone to know.

I was trying to remember the name of the Liverpool defender who brought ohare down for the pen.i remember it was a very controversial decision at the time.the media were all over it.
A few seasons later I don't recall anyone other than City fans giving any attention to Alf grey ruling out Kevin Reeves header in the league cup semi final.maybe because it wasn't shown ' live ' iirc.

Liverpool had the benefit of ludicrous media favouritism, even in those days, and that's remained constant between then and the present. I remember in 1991, I'd been in Russia for the summer and flew back into Heathrow on the day we beat Forest 2-1 at Maine Road with that header by Andy Hill from the edge of the box. (I clearly remember listening to it on the radio while staying over with some mates in London).

Two days later, I was back at my parents' house and watched the Granada Friday evening football preview show Kick Off, hosted by Elton Welsby. Because I know I returned when we beat Forest, I can date that to precisely 16 days after we won 2-1 against Liverpool, the game in David White's second goal was a Geoff Hurst-style effort, coming down off the bar. And, even more than two weeks after the event, Granada devoted five minutes of their show to bleating about White's effort not having crossed the line.

It was sickening, but typical. I started watching football in the mid-seventies, and the media has pumped out nauseating pro-Liverpool propaganda like that for as long as I remember.
 
The goalkeeper at the other end (who Clough later bought for a then world record for a GK) allowed a shot to squeeze under his body which should have been a routine save for an international GK. There again, I thought Shilton was very overrated and had serious shortcomings particularly a lack of height and mobility towards the middle and later parts of his career.
That penalty shootout, think it was v West Germany, watch Shiltons' dives, he just flops to one side on each of his attempts, no spring in his legs whatsoever, he'd well and truly gone by that stage, disappointing, knowing that we were likely out after the first penalty, he wasn't getting anything that wasn't hit straight at him :-(.
 
Allison said when looking back at his career that his biggest regret was coming back to City. Steve Daley said he signed a TEN year contract when he joined us and was totally deflated when the move proved so disastrous. The harder he tried the worse it got for him with the crowd expectation proving too much for him to overcome. He realised the only option for him was to move abroad and left for Seattle. Allison always said he agreed a fee for Daley of £600,000 with Wolves over the phone but then returned from holiday only to find Swales had gone and offered £1,437,500 which Wolves of course snatched his hand off at and never mentioned their previous negotiations with Allison !
I bet they banked that cheque with some speed !
I've always had a bit of sympathy for Daley, I've said before, the press were out to break him before he'd kicked a ball in my view, he was a good player and put in quite a few 8/10 performances for us, and yet the next day they'd score him 5's and 6's at best.
Oddly, I 'd been watching a fair bit of a lad at W.B.A called Robson and said numerous times HE was the one we should be going for.
 
No one disputes that Allison chose the players. But in Tony Book's autobiography, he definitely states that Swales negotiated the fees and I think that Tony was probably better placed than anyone to know.



Liverpool had the benefit of ludicrous media favouritism, even in those days, and that's remained constant between then and the present. I remember in 1991, I'd been in Russia for the summer and flew back into Heathrow on the day we beat Forest 2-1 at Maine Road with that header by Andy Hill from the edge of the box. (I clearly remember listening to it on the radio while staying over with some mates in London).

Two days later, I was back at my parents' house and watched the Granada Friday evening football preview show Kick Off, hosted by Elton Welsby. Because I know I returned when we beat Forest, I can date that to precisely 16 days after we won 2-1 against Liverpool, the game in David White's second goal was a Geoff Hurst-style effort, coming down off the bar. And, even more than two weeks after the event, Granada devoted five minutes of their show to bleating about White's effort not having crossed the line.

It was sickening, but typical. I started watching football in the mid-seventies, and the media has pumped out nauseating pro-Liverpool propaganda like that for as long as I remember.
Was at Maine rd for both those matches,the Tues night midweek game for both David White goals partc stands out,the Kippax was bouncing.
Steve Mcmanaman made his debut for Liverpool wearing no.9 upfront and scored their goal with a diving header,Dean Saunders missed a pen
It was all going off.

I'd never seen City beat Liverpool before ,.. after all those heavy defeats in the 70s and 80s (Dalglish turning Caton inside out twice before dispatching past Corrigan at Platt lane -ouch) and who can forget the George Courtney influenced fa cup quarter final at Maine rd when we were 2nd division with a team full of home grown but inexperienced talent and they were the best team in the country...
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.