NQCitizen
Well-Known Member
My eyes do not lie to me, nothing you say will convince me he's at the level required to play for city and I've not seen enough from him to suggest he ever will be. He's ineffective on the ball, criminally lazy off it and not suited physically or mentally to play in the Premier League.
Does my head in when I see the 'Mahrez at 21' argument too because it's just clutching at straws. The two are incomparable - I bet you anything Savinho won't be anywhere near Mahrez at 26.
How on earth have you come to the conclusion of him being top 5-10 RW in the world? Because of a few assists (7 of his 10) against relegated or poor bottom-half sides last season? Sorry but that's a laughable statement.
All the new contract has done is given him comfort to not have to perform, it already looks as though he's less motivated/ interested after it.
He was 4th in Ballon D'or young player voting. The attackers ahead of him were Guler and Yamal, who are obviously better. Doue and Barcola are and Estevao will be if he keeps it up.
That's right wingers in his age bracket. Assuming they mature at relatively similar rates they likely end up in the 10 best RWs at their peaks.
He was in the La Liga TOTY at 19 and our top assister at 20. He's out of form and getting booed by his own fans may not help him out of it. He may even leave. But if he shows anything like the Girona form for another team it'll be another Palmer, Soriano is not necessarily wrong.
He may not be great in your eyes but I'm more inclined to trust Pep, Viana, Txiki and Soriano.