Bluewonder
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 24 Jun 2013
- Messages
- 4,698
And he gives away plenty of goals with his feet too.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
31 | Ederson - 2024/25
- Thread starter MCFCFanTX
- Start date
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
when you have a top player so close to join Saudi league for 3x the salary and 10x lesser professional level they are basically ready to check out from elite football.
should have Liverpool hold onto Henderson, Fabinho when they were happy to go to Saudis? not at all. they used that to actually charge the buyers more...
problem is he did check out imo but we were adamant to keep him still.
should have Liverpool hold onto Henderson, Fabinho when they were happy to go to Saudis? not at all. they used that to actually charge the buyers more...
problem is he did check out imo but we were adamant to keep him still.
NQCitizen
Well-Known Member
That’s great. Apart from the fact he was at fault for the 2 goals that lost us this tie tonight.
For me the kick was a mistake, but any aggressive keeper is coming to meet Vini there, you don't see many stay on their line.That’s great. Apart from the fact he was at fault for the 2 goals that lost us this tie tonight.
Both those goals were defendable, hardly Ederson solely responsible.
mexico1970
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 30 Jun 2019
- Messages
- 33,084
- Team supported
- Manchester City
Ederson doesn't fill me with any confidence any more, Ortega gets the yips too.
Perhaps it's time to dig Carson up to give him a few games.
Perhaps it's time to dig Carson up to give him a few games.
Johnny Mars Bar
Well-Known Member
when you have a top player so close to join Saudi league for 3x the salary and 10x lesser professional level they are basically ready to check out from elite football.
should have Liverpool hold onto Henderson, Fabinho when they were happy to go to Saudis? not at all. they used that to actually charge the buyers more...
problem is he did check out imo but we were adamant to keep him still.
The Saudi thing was never real though according to some folk on here, because the story originated from Sam Lee and he is unreliable because….reasons?… and Ederson’s girlfriend denied it on Instagram.
mancity111
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 28 Dec 2013
- Messages
- 1,417
He most likely will be gone in the summer like many others.
this 100%. Will always be grateful for his performance in the CL final against Inter but well past time to go now.when you have a top player so close to join Saudi league for 3x the salary and 10x lesser professional level they are basically ready to check out from elite football.
should have Liverpool hold onto Henderson, Fabinho when they were happy to go to Saudis? not at all. they used that to actually charge the buyers more...
problem is he did check out imo but we were adamant to keep him still.
The kick for the second was terrible, but his attempted save, pushing it out to he most dangerous area was also shocking
Agree. Miskicks and stuff like that happen. The save was just poor goalkeeping. Keepers used to catch those! Even discounting that, there was one place to not push it out to, but that's where it ended up.
BLUEisville
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 13 Apr 2014
- Messages
- 492
Worse than that, he didn't even have his hands up, tried to save with his chestThe kick for the second was terrible, but his attempted save, pushing it out to he most dangerous area was also shocking
I can't decide which option annoys me more: he was either too slow to get ready for the shot everyone knew was coming, or he stupidly thought that trying to control it with his chest instead of doing absolutely anything else was a good idea.
decmancity
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 7 Nov 2010
- Messages
- 14,533
The hilarious part about the kick is that as the cross comes in, Shearer is signing his praises for it being a good decision to just collect it, calm the game down and then he goes and does that.
Churchlawtonblue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 17 May 2009
- Messages
- 16,617
We said the same thing in the north stand right behind him. Then he does that. Total idiot.The hilarious part about the kick is that as the cross comes in, Shearer is signing his praises for it being a good decision to just collect it, calm the game down and then he goes and does that.
super_city_si
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 29 Dec 2007
- Messages
- 53,461
Thats how goalies are tought now. They keep their hands low.Worse than that, he didn't even have his hands up, tried to save with his chest
I can't decide which option annoys me more: he was either too slow to get ready for the shot everyone knew was coming, or he stupidly thought that trying to control it with his chest instead of doing absolutely anything else was a good idea.
Bluesince1979
Well-Known Member
And not move them ? :))Thats how goalies are tought now. They keep their hands low.
Millwallawayveteran1988
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 23 Sep 2010
- Messages
- 41,998
Definately went to the same school as Nunes when brains were being handed out.
BlueMoonRisin’
Well-Known Member
An idiot that won us the CL with a world class save?Ederson is physically gifted but he's as dumb as a box of rocks. Some mistake how dumb he is with him being a cool customer when in reality he's an idiot...
He's an idiot. World class save or Lukaku hitting him with his wide open header?An idiot that won us the CL with a world class save?
BlueMoonRisin’
Well-Known Member
He's been an integral part of our success and owns the term 'sweeper keeper' and twice you've called him an idiot.He's an idiot. World class save or Lukaku hitting him with his wide open header?
I suggest you look in the mirror and you'll soon see what an idiot looks like.
But they're not meant to keep them in their pocketsThats how goalies are tought now. They keep their hands low
Mad_fer_it
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 11 Feb 2011
- Messages
- 725
Like a lot of the current squad Ederson peaked upon sealing the Treble. He's been getting worse ever since. This season has seen a dramatic drop off. Sad but there's little room for sentiment if you want to win stuff at this level and that's what Pep and the recruitment team have been guilty of IMO.
Anyway, Eddie and Walker should have been replaced post treble season.
Bernardo, Grealish and Akanji should have been replaced last summer.
KDB you could argue should have been replaced last summer too. Though I'd keep him on as he can become our Modric if hes willing to accept that role. He can be a game changer even if he's having a shit day but it's clear he can't last more than 60mins
They've all been legends. Anyone part of the squad in the last 4 years will go down in City history but father time catches up with everyone at some point. We've absolutely squeezed every drop out of this squad and it's telling now.
These players plus Gundo and Nunes need to go. Gundo absolute hero but looks leggy. Nunes just isn't good enough and with summer recruits coming in, the man has no place in the squad tbh.
The likes of Rico and Kovacic should be bench warmers (particularly Rico - I don't think he'll ever be good enough to start but he's young and could improve, ya never know, stranger things have happened).
Hopefully the summer revamp revitalises Foden and he can form part of the new core crop of players. If summer recruitment goes well the group that are left (Haaland, Marmoush, Foden, Nico, Rodri, Dias, Gvardiol, Stones + Reis & Khusanov) can form a team capable of challenging for multiple major honors again.
Ake. Great servant but will there be room for him after the summer especially with his with his age and injury record this year?
Savinho & Doku - the jury is out on them. Both have been inconsistent. On current form, I'm not sure either can become world class like their most obvious past comparators - Mahrez and Sane respectively. McAtee - is he good enough? Seen glimpses of brilliance but can he step up and be a genuine starting XI contender? It's these players just below the starting XI that have a massive impact on success. They have to be putting enough pressure on starters know those in the 1st XI can't drop their levels for fear of being dropped. At the moment nobody at this level of the squad seems good enough to this.
Bobb is our best promising youngster and I'm sure will be immense for us. Hopefully Echeverri can follow but I know little about him. Likewise with McFarlane, how much can he push our senior LB for a place?
We have a massive job in the summer. Hope the fucking club world cup bollocks doesn't ruin everything.
But yeah Ederson - time to go mate. It's been good but nothing lasts forever.
Anyway, Eddie and Walker should have been replaced post treble season.
Bernardo, Grealish and Akanji should have been replaced last summer.
KDB you could argue should have been replaced last summer too. Though I'd keep him on as he can become our Modric if hes willing to accept that role. He can be a game changer even if he's having a shit day but it's clear he can't last more than 60mins
They've all been legends. Anyone part of the squad in the last 4 years will go down in City history but father time catches up with everyone at some point. We've absolutely squeezed every drop out of this squad and it's telling now.
These players plus Gundo and Nunes need to go. Gundo absolute hero but looks leggy. Nunes just isn't good enough and with summer recruits coming in, the man has no place in the squad tbh.
The likes of Rico and Kovacic should be bench warmers (particularly Rico - I don't think he'll ever be good enough to start but he's young and could improve, ya never know, stranger things have happened).
Hopefully the summer revamp revitalises Foden and he can form part of the new core crop of players. If summer recruitment goes well the group that are left (Haaland, Marmoush, Foden, Nico, Rodri, Dias, Gvardiol, Stones + Reis & Khusanov) can form a team capable of challenging for multiple major honors again.
Ake. Great servant but will there be room for him after the summer especially with his with his age and injury record this year?
Savinho & Doku - the jury is out on them. Both have been inconsistent. On current form, I'm not sure either can become world class like their most obvious past comparators - Mahrez and Sane respectively. McAtee - is he good enough? Seen glimpses of brilliance but can he step up and be a genuine starting XI contender? It's these players just below the starting XI that have a massive impact on success. They have to be putting enough pressure on starters know those in the 1st XI can't drop their levels for fear of being dropped. At the moment nobody at this level of the squad seems good enough to this.
Bobb is our best promising youngster and I'm sure will be immense for us. Hopefully Echeverri can follow but I know little about him. Likewise with McFarlane, how much can he push our senior LB for a place?
We have a massive job in the summer. Hope the fucking club world cup bollocks doesn't ruin everything.
But yeah Ederson - time to go mate. It's been good but nothing lasts forever.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.