Surprised me as I always thought of him as a pure defender with an eye for a great pass and the odd goal. The most disappointing thing today was his positioning which gave them so much space and then when you allow players with pace to run at you you are screwed. He needs to work on being more assertive and also work on his passes - too many times he chose to go back to Eddie, which conceded space. I know it we use that system a lot but when John plays there he also closes the space and offers himself for a return pass.