We are judging him and should be judging him on being a clutch player in the big games and sadly most of us would not want to see him in any of those games.
The stats suggest he is a reliable goalscorer and assister which he has been in 2 seasons however can anyone confidently say he will score a sitter or a 1v1 without doubting that he will. We are at a point where we are not surprised if he misses an open goal 3 yards out aka Lyon or the fact he is so hopeless when he is 1v1 and these are not doubts we should be having for a player of his supposed calibre. Adding to that he has been embarrassing trying to beat a man this season running into them or over running the ball, basic things a “world class” player should be doing.
To clarify I used to be a big Sterling supporter willing him to do well and believe he would go from strength to strength with age instead of regressing. It is just difficult to ever see him reach a level where you can consider him reliable.
in saying all of that, his comments recently suggest something might have been going on behind the scenes which has not helped whatever that may be. I would happily admit i am wrong if he kicks on again this season but at the moment and for the last 2 years he has been disrupting the flow of our team and not fitting in to the style, he just has nowhere near the required level of technical ability.