Then you would be wrong in your thinking. I can and do appreciate the contribution to the team, but I can also not rate him as a top player.
For me, he has poor touch, control and decision making evidenced in most games he plays . He is the epitome of Jeckyll and Hyde in that you never know at any moment in a game which one is getting the ball or opportunity.
Furthermore, he is already up there as one of our highest earners and reputedly, wants compatibility with the top, and frankly, imo, he doesn't justify that.
It's good that he is improving with his contributions once again, but for what I say above, I don't rate him as highly as others.
Hope that clears things up for you.