Alexis Sanchez

Status
Not open for further replies.
RoslerThe2nd said:
Ozil won our player of the year award in 15/16 and was irrelevant after January? It means nothing who wins the individual award.

Okay tell me this, if David Silva was so good why didn't he get nominated for the PFA player of the year award?
Click to expand...

The fact Kyle Walker won the young award over Kun in our 1st PL title winning season tells you everything you need to know about that award.

In fact, Kun was on the shortlist for the main award as well but Walker wasn't. So by the PFA's amazing logic, a young player who wasn't nominated for the top award was a more worthy candidate than a player who was nominated for both.

Also, Giggs won the thing after player 11 league games in a season.

If you're going to try and slag Dave off, at least give some credible evidence.

If Dave played for United, Arsenal, Spurs or Liverpool he'd have been knighted by now.
 
RoslerThe2nd said:
No I actually watched City a lot as many of your games were televised. I didn't notice him at all, KDB was noticed a hell of a lot more and what a player btw. Silva played in 34 games last season and only managed 4 goals and 7 assists. For me, in your team, that is shocking for a so called world class attacker.
Click to expand...

That's just confirmed it, going with the stats and the MOTD highlights.

The season before last Silva was being written off as finished while injured by some on here, while KDB was being lauded as the second coming of Christ.

But based on last season, you'll struggle to find a single poster who thought KDB was better than Silva, irrespective of the "numbers".

You've clearly not been watching our games if you think Silva was an "attacker" last seaaon. He played in midfield for 90% of the time.

Also, judging him by assists and goals is actually laughable in it's misunderstanding of football. Check out Zidane's stats at Madrid. Check out Xavi and Iniesta's at Barca. They're similar / worse to Silva's at City. Then go and ask Madrid and Barca fans what they thought of those players.

Judge players on performances, not Fantasy Football stats and MOTD highlights.
 
RoslerThe2nd said:
I literally said Silva dropped off, meaning that he's dropped off from when he was in his absolute prime for you guys, and some have had a hissy fit about it? :/

Isn't it obvious that a 31 year old would drop off from previous seasons? Like is that really a bad thing to say :/
Click to expand...
It. Was. His. Best. Season.

It's not a bad thing to say. It's just fucking wrong.
 
RoslerThe2nd said:
Walker? The last 5 winners have been -

Kante
Mahrez
Hazard
Suarez
Bale

All worthy winners.
Click to expand...
It was young player he's referring to. In answer to your original question the same reason why both our title winning managers failed to win manager of the year.
 
RoslerThe2nd said:
No I agree, hence why Kante was nominated. I'm just saying lads, if Aguero and Silva truly had their best ever seasons in city shirts last season they would've at least been nominated to be the PFA player of the year. They've been nominated other times in the past 5 seasons when they've had their true best seasons in City shirts.
Click to expand...

You sir are deluded.
 
daztrueblue91 said:
The fact Kyle Walker won the young award over Kun in our 1st PL title winning season tells you everything you need to know about that award.

In fact, Kun was on the shortlist for the main award as well but Walker wasn't. So by the PFA's amazing logic, a young player who wasn't nominated for the top award was a more worthy candidate than a player who was nominated for both.

Also, Giggs won the thing after player 11 league games in a season.

If you're going to try and slag Dave off, at least give some credible evidence.

If Dave played for United, Arsenal, Spurs or Liverpool he'd have been knighted by now.
Click to expand...

i'm not slagging dave off at all, read my posts? All I've said is he's dropped off? Is that slagging off? No it isn't in the slightest.
 
I preferred this thread when it contained actual news about Alexis potentially joining us. Now it's just full of wumming Gooners.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
✖
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.