lancs blue said:
SuperMario's Fireworks. said:
The club needs to move the away fans, and allow the South Stand to be a standing singing section, if that can be made possible the atmosphere will hugely improve. Having a dedicated large section should help the atmosphere to catch on around the stadium.
No, it won't improve at all, you need away fans on L1 as well as a unified, dedicated City end to make the atmosphere better, that's why I'd make the North stand L1 the home end for the singers.
It seems that most of us agree that CITY must have one, complete `end` located at level one of the stadium for the more vocal supporters rather than the `singing` fans ( I recognise that other fans sing in other parts of the stadium), rather than being split in two as at present which does not happen at any other club in the world.
If we accept that having one `end` will be better for lots of reasons then the next matter to resolve is which end?
IF we were moving from Maine Road to The Etihad now I would have established the North Stand.Level One as the CITY `end` and had the away fans at the other end, in the current position, for crowd control purposes and access to coaches/cars on the dedicated car park. Lets not forget though that at almost every away ground most away fans just leave the stadium and immediately mix with home supporters. In any case at CITY this soon happens when away fans exit on to Ashton New Road.
In theory, but it would require some effort and planning, this could still happen by transferring all the level one North Stand seasoncard holders to the South Stand level one and vice-versa plus relocating the East Stand `Kippax` corner to the North Stand. However this would still mean locating the away fans to the new Level Three of the South Stand. The Club have however worked hard to attract families to matches and to create special amenities in the North Stand and outside. Arguably the entire North Stand is too large just for families and maybe having a completely full upper tier only would have been better but we should acknowledge that the Club is trying to cater for fans of all ages across different price ranges and does more than any other club that I am aware of. We should applaud the many good things that CITY do.
My view is that,overall, at the current time the best option is to easily create for season 2015/16 a complete CITY`end` at level One of the South Stand with the East Stand corner being transferred to the seats currently occupied by away fans. The away fans should then be relocated to the new Level Three of the South Stand which is big enough for all PL away allocations of up to 3,000 . On those Cup matches where the away fans are entitled to and can take up a bigger allocation, the entire third level of circa 6,000 tickets, should be allocated. This will significantly reduce crowd control inside the stadium as the away fans will, in effect, be in their own stand,similar to when we go to Stretford for cup matches.
One of the last options I saw from the Club was to allocate away fans on three levels of the South Stand but in narrower and smaller blocks. Arguably this would be better than at present as it will probably dissipate the vocal away support to some extent but would still require lots of stewarding /policing inside the ground; would result in the loss of seats /income due to segregation; and would still require similar levels of policing outside the stadium.
What are the thoughts of other Blues?