Balotelli and Tevez

[Damocles]

Even on this forum with all the rags wums you really struggle to find most people comming out and saying they want Ibra at city.

I'd love Ibra here, but not at the cost of Tevez, who is our talisman. He's as important to us as Rooney is to United, or Messi to Barcelona.

 

[Blue Elmo]

Even on this forum with all the rags wums you really struggle to find most people comming out and saying they want Ibra at city.

I'd love Ibra here, but not at the cost of Tevez, who is our talisman. He's as important to us as Rooney is to United, or Messi to Barcelona.

Totally agree , the backbone of our new look city if we get rid then I don't think we would be able to find alot better in that role .

 

[Damocles]

You see, *I* object to those 'stats'. Balo has played nowhere near the amount of games as Tevez, so his goal record per game means next to nothing.

This is a very idiotic comment. How are you supposed to compare them if they haven't played the same number of games - goal per game ratio is obvously the best comparision method.

Furthermore, Balotelli has played 60 games since 2007 tevez 90. 2/3 Is hardly NOTHING.

Goals per game means entirely nothing. Tevez regularly came on for United for 5 minutes at the end of a game, which still hits his GPG ratio. Also, tevez was playing at a higher standard, in a different team, in a different position, etc.

If GPG is the only measure of success, Van Nistelrooy is a far better player than Baggio, which is ludicrous.

 

[Sabster]

This is a very idiotic comment. How are you supposed to compare them if they haven't played the same number of games - goal per game ratio is obvously the best comparision method.

Furthermore, Balotelli has played 60 games since 2007 tevez 90. 2/3 Is hardly NOTHING.

Goals per game means entirely nothing. Tevez regularly came on for United for 5 minutes at the end of a game, which still hits his GPG ratio. Also, tevez was playing at a higher standard, in a different team, in a different position, etc.

If GPG is the only measure of success, Van Nistelrooy is a far better player than Baggio, which is ludicrous.

I am not saying it is a great measure. But it is a very good measure.

And furthermore the same can be said about ballotelli coming from the bench - which he has done a lot more than tevez<br /><br />-- Mon Jun 14, 2010 3:54 pm --<br /><br />

Lol Ibra better than Tevez. I gurantee not in the prem. 1000% he wouldnt get as many goals, wouldnt get as many assists would not contibute anywhere near as much to the team. Like I said simply cant take you seriously !

I cannot make the comment the Ibra would do definately better than tevez. (Unlike you who can somehow make the comment that tevez would do better than Ibra - just shows your bias yet again). But Ibra would offer an outlet ball and would hold the ball up something tevez does not, scondly he has scored far more than tevez over the past few years. And this season he got more assists.

This is the sort of biased crap I am referring to - you spouting rubbish that Ibra would definately do worse than tevez.

 

[Mancio]

lippi's choice are right like the capello's one.

or , maybe , do you think green is better than hart or SWP than AJ ?

Hart and AJ were in contention. Balo is the seventh choice striker for Italy now. Try comparing Green to Scott Carson and you're more along the right lines.

mate , I think you are a reasonable person.
then I ask you a question.

If you could buy one of Gilardino, Pazzini, Quagliarella, Rossi, Borriello Iaquinta and Balotelli, who would you buy?

 

[mike channon´s windmill]

Lets be honest anyone that goes and watch city every other week is not going to agree to the sale of Tevez under any circumstances, regardless to the players we are offered or will sign. Hes that important to our team. Cant see how we would have finished in the top 6 last season without Tevez its that big a deal.

I dont know any city fan that would agree to his sale, I am talking people that actually go to games that I know in person not taking large on internet forums.

Lol Ibra better than Tevez. I gurantee not in the prem. 1000% he wouldnt get as many goals, wouldnt get as many assists would not contibute anywhere near as much to the team. Like I said simply cant take you seriously !

Even on this forum with all the rags wums you really struggle to find most people comming out and saying they want Ibra at city.

^^^ Top post

After all we went through to get him last year this would be fookin madness and as far as I´m concerned would seal Mancini´s fate - I wouldn´t want the coont near COMS if he went ahead with this - we should be telling Moratti , the fat waiter and Inter to fook right off - simples

 

[Ticket For Schalke]

Hart and AJ were in contention. Balo is the seventh choice striker for Italy now. Try comparing Green to Scott Carson and you're more along the right lines.

mate , I think you are a reasonable person.
then I ask you a question.

If you could buy one of Gilardino, Pazzini, Quagliarella, Rossi, Borriello Iaquinta and Balotelli, who would you buy?

Di Natale

 

[alera]

I'd love Ibra here, but not at the cost of Tevez, who is our talisman. He's as important to us as Rooney is to United, or Messi to Barcelona.

Dont get me wrong I would have him the question is at what cost.

Sell rsc, get ibra as his replacement for Robinho and say £15 million or so yes I am up for that sort of deal.

Be we know in reality if we sign him it would mean the loss of Ade (Guranteed 20 prem goals a season) or worse case Tevez.

Plus Barca want stupid deals from city it would seem so something like £30 million and Robinho for Ibra.

That sort of deal and sacrafice no thanks I dont know anyone who would want something like that happening.

 

[Mancio]

mate , I think you are a reasonable person.
then I ask you a question.

If you could buy one of Gilardino, Pazzini, Quagliarella, Rossi, Borriello Iaquinta and Balotelli, who would you buy?

Di Natale

LOL ;=)

 

[Oasis_City]

Super Mario and Superman!