Balotelli, Boateng, Kolarov, Silva, Yaya Toure, Milner

[Gelsons Dad]

Milner has 4 assists to his name this season. Silva has 2.

There are some odd assessments in this list.

 

[leewill31]

Milner has 4 assists to his name this season. Silva has 2.

There are some odd assessments in this list.

i am glad somebody else noticed this!!

its looking like barry has competition for his most underrated player trophy :)

 

[cityboy1]

Milner has 4 assists to his name this season. Silva has 2.

There are some odd assessments in this list.

i am glad somebody else noticed this!!

its looking like barry has competition for his most underrated player trophy :)

hes good in the middle
hes shit on the wings

 

[1fingerwillie]

Milner has 4 assists to his name this season. Silva has 2.

There are some odd assessments in this list.

This.

 

[leewill31]

i am glad somebody else noticed this!!

its looking like barry has competition for his most underrated player trophy :)

hes good in the middle
hes shit on the wings

get used to him playing were ever he is needed and doing 100% every game,after just over 16 games i wont be slating him just yet!

 

[chedinho]

Milner has 4 assists to his name this season. Silva has 2.

There are some odd assessments in this list.

i am glad somebody else noticed this!!

its looking like barry has competition for his most underrated player trophy :)

im guessing,but has milner had more game time?silva should score more goals considering the chances and positions he gets in.

they are all great players,its easier to say,that at the moment boateng is taking the longest to settle.a bit like de jong in his 1st season,you can tell he is quality,just needs to feel more comfortable in his new surroundings.

 

[blackley macca]

Silva.

 

[simon23]

think we will have a better view at the end of the season......

however balotelli has made an immediate impression in not many games...same as kolorov

Yaya - bit hit and miss for me at present
silva - his ability on the ball stands out a mile
bosteng - obviously not upto speed yet but we all saw how good a player he was at the world cup
milner - 100% every game but from an attacking point of view (even if he does have 4 assists) in my opinion he has been a let down....the one thing i expected from miler other than effort was decent delivery into the box and that has been pretty lacking so far

 

[Joga Bonito]

If we can keep Mancini we can keep Balotelli and if things work out...I have said too much

I really admire Toure I think he is a near perfect box-to-bx player.

Only player I have disappointed with is Milner but I believe he still has a good role to play.

As Boateng said he has yet to his his form

 

[kun]

Silva - 9 - Brilliant so far, on of the top play-makers in Europe IMO, excellent passing, utterly impresed.
Best moment: Goal vs Blackpool
Worst moment: game vs Tottenham, looked average

Balotelli - 7.5 - Impressed in glimpses, but has shown his bad side, more to come me thinks.
Best moment: Goal on his debut, vs Timosoara
Worst moment: red card vs WBA

Kolarov - 7 - Looks good, but hasn't had enough time to show it yet.
Best moment: Breakaways vs Fulham
Worst moment: seeing red vs Bolton

Y. Toure - 7 - Decent, good running, played out of position IMO
Best moment: Goal vs Fulham
Worst moment: Game vs Wolves

Boateng - 6 - Not very good so far but he will improve, I think
Best moment: assist for barry in pre-season
Worst moment: a couple of his long range shots have been abysmal

Milner - 5 - Awful so far, hopefully better to come
Best moment: Liverpool game
Worst moment: Every other game