Battle of the Bands Final - Beatles v Rolling Stones 217

[another generation]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Jam v Pink Floyd page 37

The Jam.

 

[manclad]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Clash v Oasis page 25

27-24 to Oasis in the mother of all battles.

Round 1 Matchday 6 -
The Jam.............................................................................................Pink Floyd

please, 1st voter, quote this so it's at the top of the page.

the jam

They smelt of pubs and Wormwood Scrubs,
And too many right wing meetings.

Woking's finest trio - The Jam.

 

[Deleted member 14625]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Jam v Pink Floyd page 37

Now then. This is a tough one.

The Jam, without ever making musical masterpieces, we're a consistently good tunes band; Pink Floyd made some of the most overrated guff I've heard but also some musical masterpieces.

I think my favourite songs of the two bands are "Ibiza Bar" and "Echoes", both by Pink Floyd. But their later albums were not good.

I'm stumped!

...

Because at their best they were better I'm going for Floyd (I might come back and vote for The Jam though ;) !)

 

[Totnes Blue]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Jam v Pink Floyd page 37

Pink Floyd.

 

[PistonBlue]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Jam v Pink Floyd page 37

The Jam were good but Floyd were on another level and win hands down for me.

Pink Floyd

 

[Zubrman]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Jam v Pink Floyd page 37

Singles - Jam

Albums - Floyd

Value for money - Floyd

 

[scenecreamer]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Jam v Pink Floyd page 37

The Jam

 

[Cellarite]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Jam v Pink Floyd page 37

Singles - Jam

Albums - Floyd

Value for money - Floyd

and your vote?

 

[BTH]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Jam v Pink Floyd page 37

Floyd

 

[GStar]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Jam v Pink Floyd page 37

Pink