You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Battle of the XI's: La Liga v Prem v Serie A v Bundesliga
- Thread starter Latics Fan SJK
- Start date
A
A
Anonymous
Guest
no offence o.p..
but those teams aren't anywhere near the best in their respected leagues.
but those teams aren't anywhere near the best in their respected leagues.
Latics Fan SJK
Well-Known Member
ban-mcfc said:no offence o.p..
but those teams aren't anywhere near the best in their respected leagues.
No offence, but it's all about opinions, isn't it?
Everyone will have their own "best XI". Unless I have actually forgotten someone, then those are my teams. (although I will admit that Boateng, looking back, is a questionable inclusion).
Mentions of Totti & De Rossi went ignored, as I wouldn't have them either.
Josh Blue
Well-Known Member
Neither of the Boatengs should be in the teams. Are you part of the family?
sjk2008 said:ban-mcfc said:no offence o.p..
but those teams aren't anywhere near the best in their respected leagues.
No offence, but it's all about opinions, isn't it?
Everyone will have their own "best XI". Unless I have actually forgotten someone, then those are my teams. (although I will admit that Boateng, looking back, is a questionable inclusion).
Mentions of Totti & De Rossi went ignored, as I wouldn't have them either.
You obviously know your stuff
Latics Fan SJK
Well-Known Member
simmers said:sjk2008 said:ban-mcfc said:no offence o.p..
but those teams aren't anywhere near the best in their respected leagues.
No offence, but it's all about opinions, isn't it?
Everyone will have their own "best XI". Unless I have actually forgotten someone, then those are my teams. (although I will admit that Boateng, looking back, is a questionable inclusion).
Mentions of Totti & De Rossi went ignored, as I wouldn't have them either.
You obviously know your stuff
Thanks.
Why Always Ste
Well-Known Member
The OP states: the best players.
So is this based on how good they would "play" with each other, or just as individuals and put in a starting 11?
Surely you're basis is on individuals, as you put example Vidic with Kompany (and they've never played with each other)
Or Falcao infront of Iniesta and again - no game time.
So if it's based on individuals...Why when Football is a Team based sport?
It ain't The WWE.
So is this based on how good they would "play" with each other, or just as individuals and put in a starting 11?
Surely you're basis is on individuals, as you put example Vidic with Kompany (and they've never played with each other)
Or Falcao infront of Iniesta and again - no game time.
So if it's based on individuals...Why when Football is a Team based sport?
It ain't The WWE.
Latics Fan SJK
Well-Known Member
Why Always Ste said:The OP states: the best players.
So is this based on how good they would "play" with each other, or just as individuals and put in a starting 11?
Surely you're basis is on individuals, as you put example Vidic with Kompany (and they've never played with each other)
Or Falcao infront of Iniesta and again - no game time.
So if it's based on individuals...Why when Football is a Team based sport?
It ain't The WWE.
How else would you do it? Pick 11 Barca or Real and Spain players, 11 City or England players and so on?
It's hardly a topic worth delving into that much thought is it, otherwise you can throw every single "Greatest Team of All Time" list that's been drawn up in the past right out of the window.
Bloody hell.
i never heard about this el shawaary, he have to be world class to keep el shaarawy out
Marchetti; De Sciglio, Barzagli, Chiellini Balzaretti; Montolivo, De Rossi, Vidal; El Shaarawy, Cavani, Totti;
Joehannes said:Buffon; Zanetti, Barzagli, Chiellini, Balzaretti; Pirlo; Vidal, De Rossi, Marchisio; Totti, Cavani would be my Serie A XI, but it's all about opinions. Agree with earlier shouts for Muller too.
Marchetti; De Sciglio, Barzagli, Chiellini Balzaretti; Montolivo, De Rossi, Vidal; El Shaarawy, Cavani, Totti;