Bernardo Silva tweet controversy

Status
Not open for further replies.
The thing is we don't want to take away banter between mates and real racist bastards, what bernardo did was stupid but i believe there was no malice whatsoever in it.
There has to be some sort of common sense about this. If mendy hasn't taken offence in fact the complete opposite why should the fa get involved ffs
 
Last edited:
The thing is we don't want to take away banter between mates and real racist bastards, what bernardo did was stupid but i believe there was no malice whatsoever in it.
There has to be a some sort of common sense about this. If mendy hasn't taken offence in fact the complete opposite why should the fa get involved ffs
You forget that common sense and the FA don't go together.
They are a dinosaur of an organisation and the draconian logic they preach are a million miles away from the modern game.
 
Let me get this straight you don’t think the racial abuse suffered by black players in the 70s in this country and recently in Eastern Europe is any different to someone calling you a white whatever? You know nothing about the history of suppression exerted on black people? Please tell me this is not the case.
 
Being called "white trash" is not racism. It's an insult. Racism goes way deeper than just name calling. It's being denied a decent education, housing, job opportunities, and other basic human rights and priviledges only because of the the colour of your skin.

I'm a black South African and have experienced both direct and indirect racism. Do I think Silva is racist? No. Am I offended by his post? No. Having said that, he should have known better. If he wanted to make a private joke with a buddy of his, he should have kept it private.

One thing I will say is this though. The cartoon character looks nothing like Mendy. The only similarity is that they are both black. And that's where the problem lies. Maybe not for Mendy but for some people. On some level, Bernardo is aware of Mendy's blackness. That's not a bad thing because Mendy really is black. But there are people who have been discriminated against exactly for that reason: someone was aware of their blackness and used it against them in some way. The result is that they have become SENSITIVE to it. You may call them snowflakes, soft or whatever. But unless you have experienced real racism, you are in no position to judge how the people who have respond or react to certain things.
Shock, a black South African has experienced racism. I’m not being sarcastic but your former President was jailed for over 30 years for having the temerity to challenge the white authoritarianism. I think you will find we are far more tolerant and educated on this matter in the UK but it has taken a long time.

However, this has got out of hand, an innocent tweet that was a bit of fun has been hijacked by the PC brigade, it’s nothing short of ridiculous and I would argue those saying Bernie was ill advised are taking the unnecessary high ground.

Ban Bernie for a few games and let’s argue in court to see if he’s broken any rules or laws, I doubt it very much.
 
I don't see an issue with it in the context of the people involved.

It's a message FROM Bernardo TO Mendy. Not from all white people to all black people.

Is Bernardo a racist? No. Did Mendy see it as a racist tweet? No.

That's where it should end. So what if other people find it offensive. How can you be offended something that is neither aimed at you or has anything to do with you?

From what I see from that tweet he's actually saying Mendy looks like the character facially more than anything. Maybe it's face-ist.
Whilst I agree, my advice to both of them would be, if you don't want the world involved then use WhatsApp not twitter.
 
Let me get this straight you don’t think the racial abuse suffered by black players in the 70s in this country and recently in Eastern Europe is any different to someone calling you a white whatever? You know nothing about the history of suppression exerted on black people? Please tell me this is not the case.
However you have managed to ignore the history of suppression of all peoples to concentrate on just one group.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.