Big Phil Caicedo

[Arry is Bent]

No, I'm just stating the obvious. The other 2 have good track records in the top leagues and Caicedo has scored a few in the last month or so. Benjani Esq.

RSC and Ade have achieved far, far, far more in football than Phil so far. Can't believe anbody can dispute that. Phil is young and could improve, but he's not fit for our first team now and certainly not for where we're aiming.

RSC and Ade have had far, far, far more time to achieve what they have. Phil is a very good footballer and will only get better.

 

[Goater's Shin]

RSC and Ade have achieved far, far, far more in football than Phil so far. Can't believe anbody can dispute that. Phil is young and could improve, but he's not fit for our first team now and certainly not for where we're aiming.

RSC and Ade have had far, far, far more time to achieve what they have. Phil is a very good footballer and will only get better.

We can't give him that time right now, though. He's out on loan and if he proves his worth (which from the op and others he seems to be) then he can come and have a crack at it, but sadly we're not the place for him to hone his skills right now. He can make the odd appearance like Jo, but simply isn't going to get a run in the team unless he rips up trees instantly. Have a look at the Balotelli thread - Balo has significantly more potential and people aren't even willing to give him a chance to improve.

 

[conormcfc]

RSC and Ade have had far, far, far more time to achieve what they have. Phil is a very good footballer and will only get better.

We can't give him that time right now, though. He's out on loan and if he proves his worth (which from the op and others he seems to be) then he can come and have a crack at it, but sadly we're not the place for him to hone his skills right now. He can make the odd appearance like Jo, but simply isn't going to get a run in the team unless he rips up trees instantly. Have a look at the Balotelli thread - Balo has significantly more potential and people aren't even willing to give him a chance to improve.

He's the guy that started a thread slagging off Balotelli haha. Yet he still has the nerve to call others 'new fans' because they slagged off big Phil. Comical.

 

[mancmackem]

I'm not going to get into the connormcfc argument, but my order of strikers would be this at the moment with the system we play: -

Tevez
Adebayor (Probably go)
Jo (Needs to improve strength whilst on the ball)
Balotelli (A smile would do)
Caciedo (Slow but strong)
RSC (Worst signing for the money we have made, over and above Daley)
Ball (Loan)
Guidetti (Loan)

 

[Seosa]

Jo's coming along bit by bit but I agree about Santa Cruz + Bayor. Caicedo's an interesting one, another chance should definitely not be ruled out.

 

[Bill]

Jo is slowly coming good, actually. But I understand your point.

no he's not, big phil and jo along with rsc should be clearing the snow at city and nothing else.

 

[cityboy1]

Jo is slowly coming good, actually. But I understand your point.

no he's not, big phil and jo along with rsc should be clearing the snow at city and nothing else.

so whys bobby letting jo play more than ade

 

[bluealf]

A striker that gets in the box, what do we need one of them for ?

 

[Ntini77]

Not sure I'll ever be able to forgive him for that miss against Hamburg.

I'd have him here ahead of Santa though.

 

[MCFC BOB]

Jo is slowly coming good, actually. But I understand your point.

no he's not, big phil and jo along with rsc should be clearing the snow at city and nothing else.

I don't agree. Jo could be very useful in Europe as he's qgood enough to nab a few goals when we need Tevez & co. for the weekend League games.