RobMCFC
Well-Known Member
Que?
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Blue Moon Playlist Review Club - Season 2 - Episode 27 - Out on blue 6 - Gone Too Soon (pg 438)
- Thread starter RobMCFC
- Start date
They are not 'written' for the films, are they? Rehashed and renamed, more like.Que?
And yes I did go see the concert thing.
RobMCFC
Well-Known Member
You are saying that John Williams themes for Raiders of the Lost Ark, Star Wars and Jurassic Park etc ate not written for the films? As far as I am aware they are, but I'm interested to hear more.They are not 'written' for the films, are they? Rehashed and renamed, more like.
And yes I did go see the concert thing.
You are saying that John Williams themes for Raiders of the Lost Ark, Star Wars and Jurassic Park etc ate not written for the films? As far as I am aware they are, but I'm interested to hear more.
He does have a lot more you could hear.
More of the same ;).
RobMCFC
Well-Known Member
I'm guessing that you are saying that before he was commissioned to write the Star Wars score, he already had a similar piece of music? Same for Raiders and Jurassic Park?He does have a lot more you could hear.
More of the same ;).
I'm guessing that you are saying that before he was commissioned to write the Star Wars score, he already had a similar piece of music? Same for Raiders and Jurassic Park?
More or less. But it was a passing joke that doesn't merit as much expanding.
It is not that controversial a take btw, it is quite a common opinion in music. He reuses a lot.
RobMCFC
Well-Known Member
I watched this video, just out of interest.More or less. But it was a passing joke that doesn't merit as much expanding.
It is not that controversial a take btw, it is quite a common opinion in music. He reuses a lot.
The conclusion is that his main themes are not copies - but some of the incidental music may be guided by directors instructions based on a temp track they've used before the main score is composed.
threespires
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 7 Aug 2019
- Messages
- 5,987
- Team supported
- City
Vivaldi's detractors used to say he wrote the same concerto time and again so Williams is in good company.
On the (sort of) subject of Vivald, had the rules been different I would have nominated Max Richter's beautiful "On The Nature of Daylight" from Arrival which is one of my favourite films of recent years. Written prior to the film but it fits so well you could easily assume it was composed specifically for the scenes it so movingly accompanies.
Similarly though he hadn't even played it for donkeys years and was totally obscure, Anton Karas's theme for The Third Man is disqualified too sadly.
Of the big hitters no one has mentioned Michael Nyman yet. Though it's neither his best or his most successful I'm going to go with:
Chasing Sheep Is Best Left To Shepherds - Michael Nyman (from The Draughtsman's Contract)
Because...
It's a Peter Greenaway collaboration, a paring I've enjoyed over the years.
It shows the fuzzy nature of many soundtracks, though the soundtrack was 100% written for the film it deliberately reuses/riffs off elements of Purcell.
Most importantly it compliments the film brilliantly and sets a tone, aiding the narrative and another voice to that of the actors in the way that great film music should.
On the (sort of) subject of Vivald, had the rules been different I would have nominated Max Richter's beautiful "On The Nature of Daylight" from Arrival which is one of my favourite films of recent years. Written prior to the film but it fits so well you could easily assume it was composed specifically for the scenes it so movingly accompanies.
Similarly though he hadn't even played it for donkeys years and was totally obscure, Anton Karas's theme for The Third Man is disqualified too sadly.
Of the big hitters no one has mentioned Michael Nyman yet. Though it's neither his best or his most successful I'm going to go with:
Chasing Sheep Is Best Left To Shepherds - Michael Nyman (from The Draughtsman's Contract)
Because...
It's a Peter Greenaway collaboration, a paring I've enjoyed over the years.
It shows the fuzzy nature of many soundtracks, though the soundtrack was 100% written for the film it deliberately reuses/riffs off elements of Purcell.
Most importantly it compliments the film brilliantly and sets a tone, aiding the narrative and another voice to that of the actors in the way that great film music should.
OB1
Well-Known Member
Not a problem, will change, although anything by John Williams should probably be excluded as well, given they are all pretty much covers.
Man of the Hour is great but a bit dour. Unfortunately, the two Vedder songs from Dead Man Walking are not on spotify, so not looking good for the guy. The Esbjorn Svensson cover of The Face of Love is excellent, just fyi for anyone willing to give it a go.
Let's swap it to Sex Hair - Mouse Rat. At least it is original, right.
What movie was it written for?