cleavers
Moderator
So not much over a year later, he's been sold to Fiorentina "amid bullying claims" whilst at Liverpool.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Bobby Duncan
- Thread starter FantasyIreland
- Start date
asahartford1
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 15 Nov 2016
- Messages
- 8,833
Will be interesting to see how this develops. If he doesn't get in the team on a regular basis, how long will he be happy.
A good finisher, will that be enough to get regular game time, if not his agent may see Florentine as the Bully. He seemed happy enough to have signed a lucrative contract at Liverpool.
A good finisher, will that be enough to get regular game time, if not his agent may see Florentine as the Bully. He seemed happy enough to have signed a lucrative contract at Liverpool.
Gareth Barry Conlon
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 5 Sep 2014
- Messages
- 14,739
I wonder what it does to hos HG status. Presumably he will always be classed as an English association player? If so then that cements a certain amount of value. Was he with us long enoutgh to be Club trained?
Those will be big factors if he does really well out there and looking to move back to the PL? On the other hand if he doesnt break into the team he will be quickly forgotten.
Those will be big factors if he does really well out there and looking to move back to the PL? On the other hand if he doesnt break into the team he will be quickly forgotten.
Club trained is defined as 3 years with a club between ages 15-21, so no he doesn't qualify currently.I wonder what it does to hos HG status. Presumably he will always be classed as an English association player? If so then that cements a certain amount of value. Was he with us long enoutgh to be Club trained?
Those will be big factors if he does really well out there and looking to move back to the PL? On the other hand if he doesnt break into the team he will be quickly forgotten.
Centurions
Well-Known Member
He'll be like Owen Hargreaves and take up a foreign spot where ever he ends up in the future.
lightning Rodri
Well-Known Member
Isn't his case similar to Sancho's ? Both should be homegrown but not club trained ?
Whereas Hargreaves was a youth player at Canada/Germany ?
Whereas Hargreaves was a youth player at Canada/Germany ?
Last edited:
Centurions
Well-Known Member
Sancho was 17 when he left us so I'm fairly certain he's not homegrown anyway? I'm less certain on Duncan who had just turned 18 in June but can't remember if he had a period when he couldn't play for Liverpool due to their youth ban? Perhaps I've got my dates mixed up.Isn't his case similar to Sancho's ? Both should be homegrown but not club trained ?
Whereas Hargreaves was a youth player at Canada/Germany ?
Isn't his case similar to Sancho's ? Both should be homegrown but not club trained ?
Whereas Hargreaves was a youth player at Canada/Germany ?
You have to spend three years at an English club to be classed as homegrown and Sancho only spend two years with us. If he signed for us next summer then he’d qualify as homegrown and club trained after 12 months, but if he signed for us (or another PL) club when he was 21 he’d always be considered ‘foreign’.
lightning Rodri
Well-Known Member
Didn't he spent time at Watford before coming to City ?You have to spend three years at an English club to be classed as homegrown and Sancho only spend two years with us. If he signed for us next summer then he’d qualify as homegrown and club trained after 12 months, but if he signed for us (or another PL) club when he was 21 he’d always be considered ‘foreign’.