I live near Bolton, and most of them don't support Bolton, it's mostly utd and Liverpool. They have potentially got a large fan base, I believe it's the biggest town in england, but they're all glory hunters.
I made a point in the “American Sports Teams” thread in Off Topic the other day that if people were loyal to their local team, the team from the town or city that represents you as a person more than anything (more than you’re country does), then it might make them more successful or less likely to go out of business.
I’m not saying it wouldn’t happen at all, some clubs are ran terribly no matter what their fan base size is - look at City from the late ’70s, also Leeds Newcastle and Sunderland...
But if all the glory hunters who support United and Liverpool (more United shirts sold in Cardiff than Cardiff one year and more Liverpool shirts sold in Bristol than either Bristol clubs one year) from big towns and cities like Bolton Bristol Plymouth Cardiff Reading etc. then I reckon they would be in much healthier positions as a rule (with maybe the odd anomalies).
Plus the more fans you have the more you can group together and have something like a fan pressure group or even a fan takeover.
In Ireland. If everyone supported their local football teams, Ireland would definitely have a stronger league. There’s absolutely no reason why Dublin or Belfast shouldn’t have a football team that gets into the Champions League group stages like teams from other leagues that aren’t one of the top ones like Czeckia Romania Hungary Scotland etc.
People from Dublin or Bolton don’t support the Brazil or Germany national teams so why don’t they support their town/city’s teams?
People will probably think that is insular or an old fashioned way of thinking, but surely it makes sense in the train of thought of bigger core local fan base will see a club in a better position?
Saying that even clubs from bigger cities with bigger fanbases than Bolton have their fare share of fair weather fans. Look at Sheff Utd - they averaged 19000 in the third tier and now there are 30000 of them turning up now they’re in the Prem. If City and Sunderland and even Norwich can get 26-32000 average attendances in the third tier why didn’t Sheff Utd?
Even City. 54000 go to games now, almost double than what came back when we were in the third tier. The tourists weren’t turning up to be counted on to see Lee Crooks and Neil Heaney and they wouldn’t be here to be counted on if we ever find ourselves struggling again.