1961_vintage
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 21 Sep 2009
- Messages
- 15,554
Dirty business soldiering, even more so where it's guerrilla and the Geneva Convention is off the table.
kinkysleftfoot said:I served with the unit that replaced the MRF so I shall be watching this a bit later with keen interest!
pominoz said:kinkysleftfoot said:I served with the unit that replaced the MRF so I shall be watching this a bit later with keen interest!
You served with the SRU?
Respect.
Whitworth Park said:i kne albert davy said:The division of Ireland is now getting on for a century ago prior to that all Ireland was part of Great Britain longer ago than the division of India say and for every Ulsterman who wants a united Ireland you'll find a thousand in the South who wouldn't touch it with a barge pole. They are now two different countries it happens the world over.Whitworth Park said:If you looked at my other post you would see that I say that NI should remain part of the the UK until it's people decide otherwise.
What we are talking about here is not something that happened 1500 years ago.
The partition of Ireland is a relatively recent event.
I am not arguing against the reasoning as obviously the majority of the people in the North wanted it that way, and they wanted a bit more
if they could have got away with it.
I thought it was obvious that I was referring to the Catholic population of Ireland as a whole who viewed it as an occupying force not
the Protestant population of the North.
Although I do know a few Ulstermen who believe in a United Ireland and class themselves a Irish.
I really feel sorry for all the people of countries in the World that we fucked up.
Not just us, French, Dutch, Spanish and so on.
I therefore do not see because of conquest that we can claim these places as ours.
The same goes for Gibralter and The Falklands but , what's done is done and until the majority of the people in these places
and NI decide otherwise then it should remain as it is.
Perhaps I should clarify, I only know a couple of Ulstermen who class themselves as Irish, there may be others but I am sure the
majority want to stay British and I said that's how it should remain.
You are probably right as well, perhaps people of the South are a bit two faced.
Asked the question do you want a United Ireland, answer.. Yes.
Do you want the baggage that comes with it.. No.
But I do think it will happen one day, the majority now will become the minority.
Balti said:It was war
Innocents die in war but usually accidemtally
In this case the IR purposely targeted innocent people including old men and children by blowing them up usually
i don't believe that the british government stooped to that same low level even if of course innocent people suffered as they always do in war (but nowhere near as much as the IRA made them suffer of course)
kinkysleftfoot said:I served with the unit that replaced the MRF so I shall be watching this a bit later with keen interest!
mad4city said:Whitworth Park said:i kne albert davy said:The division of Ireland is now getting on for a century ago prior to that all Ireland was part of Great Britain longer ago than the division of India say and for every Ulsterman who wants a united Ireland you'll find a thousand in the South who wouldn't touch it with a barge pole. They are now two different countries it happens the world over.
I really feel sorry for all the people of countries in the World that we fucked up.
Not just us, French, Dutch, Spanish and so on.
I therefore do not see because of conquest that we can claim these places as ours.
The same goes for Gibralter and The Falklands but , what's done is done and until the majority of the people in these places
and NI decide otherwise then it should remain as it is.
Perhaps I should clarify, I only know a couple of Ulstermen who class themselves as Irish, there may be others but I am sure the
majority want to stay British and I said that's how it should remain.
You are probably right as well, perhaps people of the South are a bit two faced.
Asked the question do you want a United Ireland, answer.. Yes.
Do you want the baggage that comes with it.. No.
But I do think it will happen one day, the majority now will become the minority.
Two faced?
The people of the Republic were offered a referendum on the subject, at the time of the Good Friday agreement.
We voted to relinquish the constitutional claim on the six counties and replace it with an aspiration that the country would one day be united.
That was a step forward, made for the good of all concerned, and not an easy step either. It was made at the height of the Celtic Tiger when we (and the world's so-called, top economists) thought there would never be a poor day in Ireland again, too. So financial implications were not an issue.
There is nothing two-faced about a nation voting on an issue at the heart of its constitution. You spout about the democratic wishes of Northern Ireland but you casually insult those of the entire island.
It'd be very interesting to see, if it were put to a vote in the UK, what support there would be for re-uniting Ireland.
Then again, with over 70% of the population, up there, employed by the state, your welcome to it, as far as I'm concerned. (All else aside, you should see what I'm paying in tax, besides supporting the Norn Ironers on top of that!).
Hey, perhaps one day your country might grow up and write its constitution down, rather than making it up as it goes along - and hoodwinking its citizens (subjects?) into thinking that they're doing them a favour by perpetrating that particular, legislative, three card trick.
He rarely spoke of his time over there, but he got pissed one night and just started talking about it. I had no idea of the sort of shit he went through until then. So huge respect to any of our lads that served.