Pep responded well to criticism of City’s ‘Tackles Won’ stats a season or few back, when he said that you don’t need to tackle half so much if you have the ball for 75% of the time. So the risk of red cards for bad tackles is reduced.
Whether either could respond though to the relentless shithousery and provocation they’d get as City midfielders with enough discipline to stay on the pitch is another matter. Rodri’s the Professor of CDM-enomics - as the Alternative Commentary guy used to say - and even he lost his shit with Morgan Gibbs-White in One of this season’s defining moments.
You’re signing the person, just as much as the footballer. The Yorkshire Pirlo (ahem) was a failure of due diligence in at least one of those aspects, but there are plenty more hits than misses.
We need to find a way to build the team around Rodri, but ensure he plays fewer minutes, so gets cover by someone good enough to play the role with not a lot of drop-off but realistic enough to not want to be top dog. Not a lot of Silky Ilkays around; neither of these two seem to fit the bill.