Bruno Guimaraes

[WallyA]

Bernardo and Kovacic gone and Lewis is an emergency CM imo. He is just a utility player at the minute.

With those 2 gone, I could believe it.

But I can't see us selling Kovacic after having just bought him and him being so vital next to Rodri.

So that keeps me in the no way is this happening camp.

 

[decmancity]

With those 2 gone, I could believe it.

But I can't see us selling Kovacic after having just bought him and him being so vital next to Rodri.

So that keeps me in the no way is this happening camp.

Rumours of Saudi, he could end up funding a big chunk of Bruno.

 

[Sir Joe Aguero]

Good player no doubt, but I just don’t see a £185 midfield between him and Paqueta. Especially with the upcoming squad cost anchoring rules, that’s a massive chunk.

 

[St.Pauli support]

Good player no doubt, but I just don’t see a £185 midfield between him and Paqueta. Especially with the upcoming squad cost anchoring rules, that’s a massive chunk.

Wouldn't it a point to spend now and be prepared to a possible rules change in summer 2025?

I'm also not sure to like the idea to add Guimaraes to Arsenal's midfield.

 

[Gorbachev]

Good player no doubt, but I just don’t see a £185 midfield between him and Paqueta. Especially with the upcoming squad cost anchoring rules, that’s a massive chunk.

The going rate now unfortunately.

Chelsea destroyed the market in this country when they bough Enzo and Caicedo for the prices they did.

Plus, the days of £50m being a lot of money to a West Ham for their best player are gone. They don't get out of bed until close to 100m is being mentioned.

 

[blueparrot]

Good player no doubt, but I just don’t see a £185 midfield between him and Paqueta. Especially with the upcoming squad cost anchoring rules, that’s a massive chunk.

My issue and why I can't see it, our first choice midfield 3 would still be Rodri, Paqueta, KDB/Foden. I can't see us spending £100 mill if he doesn't get in that midfield, as a regular.

 

[meeesh]

My issue and why I can't see it, our first choice midfield 3 would still be Rodri, Paqueta, KDB/Foden. I can't see us spending £100 mill if he doesn't get in that midfield, as a regular.

Agreed, but we have a £100m player in our squad who sits on the bench quite a bit already

 

[Platt Lane 59]

Wouldn't it a point to spend now and be prepared to a possible rules change in summer 2025?

I'm also not sure to like the idea to add Guimaraes to Arsenal's midfield.

Watch a lot of Newcastle TV games, as now live in the North East.
Think Bruno is a player who does a few really good things that people notice i.e. Match of the Day moments.
Don't think he is anywhere near to being consistent enough for City or a top level team.
He also is a clumsy tackler and can easily get wound-up.
Not a Pep player...

 

[Blu3m00n91]

£100 million for him doesn’t sit right with me. We have wasted about £100 million on our last two midfield signings can’t afford another

 

[blueparrot]

£100 million for him doesn’t sit right with me. We have wasted about £100 million on our last two midfield signings can’t afford another

Kovacic money wasn't wasted, hes been a good addition for the price. Nunes we don't know yet.

 

[St.Pauli support]

Watch a lot of Newcastle TV games, as now live in the North East.
Think Bruno is a player who does a few really good things that people notice i.e. Match of the Day moments.
Don't think he is anywhere near to being consistent enough for City or a top level team.
He also is a clumsy tackler and can easily get wound-up.
Not a Pep player...

We want top class cover for Rodders to not lose every single match without him bossing our epicentre.

Who is that available 'Pep player' we should go for instead?

 

[Platt Lane 59]

Definitely agree about Kovacic.
Think he really changed the flow of the game against Forest.
Missed the BHA game, but heard he was excellent.
Rodri definitely seems more like himself when Kovacic plays alongside him.
£25 million isn't a bad price for an experienced old-head who can play the defensive midfield role if Rodri is injured or suspended ?

Kovacic money wasn't wasted, hes been a good addition for the price. Nunes we don't know yet.

 

[Gaz (FMwkdsoul)]

£100 million for him doesn’t sit right with me. We have wasted about £100 million on our last two midfield signings can’t afford another

Newcastle have made a ‘verbal agreement’ that would allow Guimaraes to speak to any Champions League club willing to offer more than £80million.

80 ok?

 

[Platt Lane 59]

We want top class cover for Rodders to not lose every single match without him bossing our epicentre.

Who is that available 'Pep player' we should go for instead?

I'm not an expert on who City should sign as "cover" for Rodri. But, I would imagine it would be someone younger than Bruno ?
But, having watched him (albeit on TV) over 12 times this season, I don't think he has the consistent quality or discipline for that role at City.
Would Bruno be prepared to be a squad player at City, as you are suggesting ?

 

[blueparrot]

We want top class cover for Rodders to not lose every single match without him bossing our epicentre.

Who is that available 'Pep player' we should go for instead?

If he is good enough to cover Rodri without any drop off, he'll want regular game time alongside Rodri in a midfield 3,not just when Rodri is rested. I don't know who but don't think that player is Guimaraes.
For me Kimmich is a far better fit because he can play as an inverted right back with Walker needing replacing.

 

[St.Pauli support]

I'm not an expert on who City should sign as "cover" for Rodri. But, I would imagine it would be someone younger than Bruno ?
But, having watched him (albeit on TV) over 12 times this season, I don't think he has the consistent quality or discipline for that role at City.
Would Bruno be prepared to be a squad player at City, as you are suggesting ?

I don't. Pep will have an idea how to play them all. Why did you think were we going for Rice? For the bench?

 

[St.Pauli support]

If he is good enough to cover Rodri without any drop off, he'll want regular game time alongside Rodri in a midfield 3,not just when Rodri is rested. I don't know who but don't think that player is Guimaraes.
For me Kimmich is a far better fit because he can play as an inverted right back with Walker needing replacing.

Bruno is too old (he is in the perfect age for midfielders in terms of experience and physicality) and you suggest Kimmich. Strange.

 

[blueparrot]

Bruno is too old (he is in the perfect age for midfielders in terms of experience and physicality) and you suggest Kimmich. Strange.

I didn't mention anyones age.

 

[St.Pauli support]

I didn't mention anyones age.

Ah sorry, mixed that up.

 

[Gabriel]

I'm not an expert on who City should sign as "cover" for Rodri. But, I would imagine it would be someone younger than Bruno ?
But, having watched him (albeit on TV) over 12 times this season, I don't think he has the consistent quality or discipline for that role at City.
Would Bruno be prepared to be a squad player at City, as you are suggesting ?

I look at Real Madrid last night and know they have Mbappe coming and others, too. Unless there is someone of proven physicality alongside Rodri, with the lungs to match, then Real's attackers will be through at our last line, and at that point it's a lottery. Some we'll keep out, some we won't. I love Neves, but I don't know if he would already be trusted in such a game next season; Guimaraes would.

We need to be able to rest Rodri, and others, far more if we are to arrive fresh in April, so everyone is going to have to curtail their expectations in regards minutes.