He was third best player last weekend, behind Bernardo and Delph. He was shite midweek because he was covering for a statue.
Well I think this is a fairly well trodden argument which can be had across four different threads in here. I like Gundogan and I'd play him on Saturday, in a different starting 11 from the one midweek. It's obviously not that ridiculous an opinion to hold as the manager seems to like him too.