City players to have played for other clubs in FA Cup Final

[xgorton]

Is Dave Bennett the only one to have played in an FA Cup final for another club and in one for City?

Dennis Tueart 73 for Sunderland and 81 for us.

 

[LongsightM13]

Dennis Tueart 73 for Sunderland and 81 for us.

Milner as well, City 2013 and the cult last year

 

[johnnytapia]

There‘s also at least one City player who appeared in a FA Cup final for City and then appeared in one against City.

Tommy Johnson?

 

[TheRubberRing]

Benjani?

 

[TheRubberRing]

Bellamy

 

[LongsightM13]

There‘s also at least one City player who appeared in a FA Cup final for City and then appeared in one against City.

Trick question Gary? Women’s team maybe?

 

[RayCTID]

Fowler

 

[gordondaviesmoustache]

Peter Doherty with Derby.

 

[Mad Eyed Screamer]

Did Fabian Delph play in a FA Cup Final for Villa?

So far I can think of 3 that have played in an FA Cup Final for City and a Final for someone else:

Gaz Baz, Lescott and Clichy

Edit: Clichy was League Cup and FA Cup . I always though Nasri was FA Cup for both. He too, was League Cup and FA Cup as was Sagna.

Patrick Vieira

 

[Mad Eyed Screamer]

There‘s also at least one City player who appeared in a FA Cup final for City and then appeared in one against City.

Are we talking 33 / 34 or 55 / 56?

 

[chaddblue]

Is Dave Bennett the only one to have played in an FA Cup final for another club and in one for City?

Vieira, Lescott?

 

[JGL07]

George Hannah played for Newcastle against City in 1955.

 

[johnnytapia]

Are we talking 33 / 34 or 55 / 56?

That’s what I thought but then looked to see if any player from our 1926 team that then played for Everton ‘34 And came up with Johnson

 

[DenisHasDoneIt]

Dennis Tueart 73 for Sunderland and 81 for us.

Spluttered on me corn flakes reading that. Could‘ve sworn Tueart didn’t play in ours. Yet there he is: last 10 minutes sub in the replay… must’ve missed that, in depths of misery

 

[Gary James]

Trick question Gary? Women’s team maybe?

Definitely not a trick question. It’s the men’s team and this player was idolised by City fans and they were extremely angry when he was sold. Crowds dropped following his departure.

 

[Gary James]

Are we talking 33 / 34 or 55 / 56?

Playing for City? None of those. Against City, yes one of those.

 

[Gary James]

Tommy Johnson?

Yes it was. 1926 for City. 1933 for Everton. He lived in Gorton and occasionally brought Dixie Dean to Gorton to have a few beers in the Plough. Wish he’d done that onthe morning of the 33 final then City might’ve stood a chance!

 

[Mad Eyed Screamer]

Yes it was. 1926 for City. 1933 for Everton. He lived in Gorton and occasionally brought Dixie Dean to Gorton to have a few beers in the Plough. Wish he’d done that onthe morning of the 33 final then City might’ve stood a chance!

That must have been some pairing!

 

[Mad Eyed Screamer]

Spluttered on me corn flakes reading that. Could‘ve sworn Tueart didn’t play in ours. Yet there he is: last 10 minutes sub in the replay… must’ve missed that, in depths of misery

Yes Tony Henry was sub in the first game, Tueart in the replay.
Henry didn't get a medal as they only made 12.

 

[kun]

back to the early 80s:

Kasper Schmeichel
Peter Schmeichel
David Seaman
David James
Shay Given
Wayne Hennessey
Stuart Taylor (unused sub)
Richard Wright (unused sub)
Carlo Nash (unused sub)
Nathan Aké (unused sub)
Joleon Lescott
Sylvain Distin
Kolo Touré
Tal Ben Haim (unused sub)
Wayne Bridge
Stuart Pearce
Terry Phelan
Andy Hinchcliffe
Patrick Vieira
Frank Lampard
Fabian Delph
Gareth Barry
Didi Hamann
Jack Rodwell (unused sub)
Nigel Clough
Shaun Wright-Phillips
James Milner
Steve McManaman
Andrei Kanchelskis
Jack Grealish
Peter Reid
Peter Beardsley
Trevor Sinclair
Scott Sinclair (unused sub)
Craig Bellamy
Andy Cole
Robbie Fowler
Nicolas Anelka
Emmanuel Adebayor (unused sub)
Daniel Sturridge
George Weah
Paul Walsh