Ederson | Deal agreed with Fenerbahce

Status
Not open for further replies.
ninjamonkey said:
Im aware he is experienced for his age, i said as much myself. You keep saying that because he has some good experience at a young age, he isn't going to gain even more and improve further, which makes zero sense.
Click to expand...
Didn't say he won't improve, I am saying if he isn't ready now or close to being ready then I fear he won't be. I then listed areas of his game to back that up and nobody has told me the areas he is going to drastically improve in. His feet won't get any better and that appears to be the biggest concern with him?
 
blueparrot said:
How will he not get better with his feet? The big part of that is decision making and spotting the right pass quickly. Both will get better with experience age and unfortunately some wrong decisions. Like any outfield player passing and the right will always improve with age.
Click to expand...
How won't he get better with his feet? The fact he will have been playing that way since he was a kid at City shows he should be levels ahead in that department already. That pass against Spurs was just stupid, people with no experience would not make that pass and as pointed out, Eddie has done that countless times and he is the best with the ball at his feet. People complained about how far Trafford can kick it (probably because we was spoilt with Ederson) That isn't going to improve is it? If we believe he is going to have a rapid improvement with the ball at his feet now, after playing it all his life, what is to say we can't do that with Donna then? Surely with him being one of if not the best shot stopper in the world, you'd take the chance of ball playing improvement with him no?
 
thegoatsthegoat said:
How won't he get better with his feet? The fact he will have been playing that way since he was a kid at City shows he should be levels ahead in that department already. That pass against Spurs was just stupid, people with no experience would not make that pass and as pointed out, Eddie has done that countless times and he is the best with the ball at his feet. People complained about how far Trafford can kick it (probably because we was spoilt with Ederson) That isn't going to improve is it? If we believe he is going to have a rapid improvement with the ball at his feet now, after playing it all his life, what is to say we can't do that with Donna then? Surely with him being one of if not the best shot stopper in the world, you'd take the chance of ball playing improvement with him no?
Click to expand...
No I wouldn't, Donnarumma hasn't got the basic passing skills Trafford has to improve on. Traffords decision making will improve.The spurs pass was a split second decision to pass to the player moving towards him when he should have decided to pass to Cherki behind him in the space Gonzalez's movement created. That will come with more experience.The thought a 22 year old keeper is at his peak and won't or can't get better all round is just madness.
 
The noises from Turkey saying Galatasaray are moving for Lammens instead of Ederson. Can’t see us going for Donnarumma if that’s the case.
 
blueparrot said:
No I wouldn't, Donnarumma hasn't got the basic passing skills Trafford has to improve on. Traffords decision making will improve.The spurs pass was a split second decision to pass to the player moving towards him when he should have decided to pass to Cherki behind him in the space Gonzalez's movement created. That will come with more experience.The thought a 22 year old keeper is at his peak and won't or can't get better all round is just madness.
Click to expand...

Interesting logic considering Ederson has got worse with his feet and decision making with age? I have explained why I don't think Trafford will improve with the ball at his feet which is a valid argument (doesn't mean it is right) but I have explained it. Don't need to anymore.
 
So Eddie goes to Gala how do you think he will get on there ? I think it won't be as easy as he possibly thinks . A keeper that can play out from the back but without a defence that can play that way, is just as bad as a defence that can play that way with a keeper that can't . I always felt Eddie found his club with City, his talents matched up perfectly with our style of play and I for one will miss him when he's gone .
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top