FA Cup Games 27/28 Jan & 6/7 Feb replays

aguero93:20 said:
It's not though, is it? These are trials.
Click to expand...

Trails or not, how many games in this round of the FA cup haven't had the so called benefit of VAR?

You are giving some clubs the benefit of a decision after the event whilst not giving it too others.

Its not fair.
 
The Light Was Yellow Sir said:
That’s not strictly true, unfortunately. It is for any goal, any penalty or non-penalty, red card incidents and mistaken identity. So, in effect, it’s being usd tonight exactly how they’ve intended it to be used, god help us.
Click to expand...

In that case I misunderstood what Riley said & a goal is from now on never a goal.until a bloke in a room sonewhere says so.
 
blueinsa said:
You think its ok to use in a competition were every side doesn't get to benefit or potentially benefit from it?

A PL side could geet all the way with home ties and the benefit of VAR here whilst a side that maybe plays away at a ground without or a side from a lower division which does not have it misses out because of a crap decision that would otherwise possibly be changed?

You cant have different rules for different sides in the same competition.
Click to expand...

Hang on what. Where have I said it's fair to use in a competition where every Side doesn't get the benefit. Show me please, you won't be able too. It's in test. It should be the same for everyone when introduced fully clearly.

Now answer what I actually said/asked....
 
aguero93:20 said:
Because it's being trialled.
Click to expand...

I know that but its changing the course of games that otherwise it wouldn't and at some point, a club will go out on a crap decision and rightly so they will ask why they dont get a second look via VAR.

By all means trial it but make sure you can trial it at every game to make it fair for all.
 
blueinsa said:
Trails or not, how many games in this round of the FA cup haven't had the so called benefit of VAR?

You are giving some clubs the benefit of a decision after the event whilst not giving it too others.

Its not fair.
Click to expand...
Trial

test (something, especially a new product) to assess its suitability or performance.

It doesn't need to be used in every game until they've optimised it, the trials are for the sake of getting VAR working as well as possible, not for the sake of having VAR in every cup match this season.
 
blueinsa said:
I know that but its changing the course of games that otherwise it wouldn't and at some point, a club will go out on a crap decision and rightly so they will ask why they dont get a second look via VAR.

By all means trial it but make sure you can trial it at every game to make it fair for all.
Click to expand...
See above.
 
Bluearmy said:
Hang on what. Where have I said it's fair to use in a competition where every Side doesn't get the benefit. Show me please, you won't be able too. It's in test. It should be the same for everyone when introduced fully clearly.

Now answer what I actually said/asked....
Click to expand...

How do you know it would have allowed our goal in the semi?

VAR does not make the decision, it just asks the ref to look again and if the ref at wembley said it was no goal then no goal it would have been.

Its completely reliant on integrity from the officials.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top