Fernandinho - 2017/18 Performances

[Colin Bells Boots]

I didnt say he was poor at any point, i said imo there was a drop in quality from him in between those seasons. Opened up to other opinions with "Coinsidence?". I then said he's obviously good enough just i dont believe he's been as motivated in previous non world cup seasons and might again lose his edge that made him outstanding in his two title wins(Still a very good player) It's really not as extreme an opinion as you like to make it look.

Sorry but I don't believe that there is any evidence whatsoever to support your assertion regarding his motivation or commitment.

 

[domalino]

I didnt say he was poor at any point, i said imo there was a drop in quality from him in between those seasons. Opened up to other opinions with "Coinsidence?". I then said he's obviously good enough just i dont believe he's been as motivated in previous non world cup seasons and might again lose his edge that made him outstanding in his two title wins(Still a very good player) It's really not as extreme an opinion as you like to make it look.

You don't think it's an extreme opinion to accuse - IMO one of our most hardworking players - of "a big drop off in quality" due to "a motivation issue" when he's not trying to catch the eye of the Brazil manager to be picked for a world cup?

I disagree. I think it's an unpleasant, baseless accusation about Fernandinho's character and commitment to the club.

 

[01cravend]

Dinho has been one of our most steady performers doing the job of 2 players when yaya couldn't be arsed,everyone dropped in the last 2 seasons of mp so not sure it's fair to single him out when everything he does is affected by the players around him and not in isolation,thats where i don't believe stats tell the whole story

Im not singling him out for criticism. Just sharing my thoughts given recent reports that we'll not be signing anyone instead of Jorginho. It's a very important position in our team and we'll need Dinho to be at his best so we can be at ours.
Merely theorized why i dont believe why Dinho was as good in other seasons we didnt win the league.

 

[01cravend]

You don't think it's an extreme opinion to accuse - IMO one of our most hardworking players - of "a big drop off in quality" due to "a motivation issue" when he's not trying to catch the eye of the Brazil manager to be picked for a world cup?

I disagree. I think it's an unpleasant, baseless accusation about Fernandinho's character and commitment to the club.

Then why do you think he wasn't as good in 14/15, 15/16 and 16/17 as he was in 13/14 and 17/18?

I'm not attacking his character. I just believe playing to go to the world cup added an edge to his game and made him a better player.

 

[01cravend]

Sorry but I don't believe that there is any evidence whatsoever to support your assertion regarding his motivation or commitment.

Nothing to do with commitment

He was a better player in our title winning/world cup seasons than he was in the others. I think it's due to the added motivation of playing his way into said world cups and nobody has offered me a counter argument other than basically getting offended that id think such a monstrous thing.

 

[Rolee]

Then why do you think he wasn't as good in 14/15, 15/16 and 16/17 as he was in 13/14 and 17/18?

I'm not attacking his character. I just believe playing to go to the world cup added an edge to his game and made him a better player.

I personally thought he was just as good in 16/17.

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

Nothing to do with commitment

He was a better player in our title winning/world cup seasons than he was in the others. I think it's due to the added motivation of playing his way into said world cups and nobody has offered me a counter argument other than basically getting offended that id think such a monstrous thing.

You're clearly on a crusade so no point in arguing with you.

However for what it is worth, your opinion is baseless and incorrect - in my opinion.

 

[bert38]

Nothing to do with commitment

He was a better player in our title winning/world cup seasons than he was in the others. I think it's due to the added motivation of playing his way into said world cups and nobody has offered me a counter argument other than basically getting offended that id think such a monstrous thing.

Counter argument as with many of our players especially as they get older is simple-they don't get a proper rest/sufficient preparation time after World Cups/Euros and therefore performance levels drop.

 

[01cravend]

You're clearly on a crusade so no point in arguing with you.

However for what it is worth, your opinion is baseless and incorrect - in my opinion.

Won't argue with me but say my opinion is baseless and incorrect so in other words you actually have nothing to say. Like getting blood from a stone trying to get another perspective out of people on here.

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

Won't argue with me but say my opinion is baseless and incorrect so in other words you actually have nothing to say. Like getting blood from a stone trying to get another perspective out of people on here.

Certain individuals have absolutely no problem voicing their perspective , as you have clearly proved. I happen to believe that you are wrong in your opinion, and this is my last response to you on the suject.

I am content to leave you on your platform which you appear to be enjoying - a " five minute of fame " cameo perhaps ?