Given or Hart?? - can we get a poll going? Poll added.

[darrenwassall]

I can see this ending up turning into a petition and being handed into Mancini just before next weeks game

 

[BlueT]

Given

 

[Stuart]

Hart . (but Given will start)

 

[stefranceuk]

I went for Given, he is at the peak age for a keeper and he has been one of the best keepers in the Premiership for years!

Joe Hart is going to be a City and England legend, one more season with Shay with Joe getting the odd game and then give Joe the number 1 jersey in a year!

 

[BLUEMOONBAZ]

Hart for me but i think it will Given who starts

 

[kennycar]

Did anyone watch the football league show, Kasper Schmeichel was immense for Lids, he really looks to have gained the extra weight he was missing for us and pulled off three of the most amazing saves. Predict him to be a big thing sooner or later, but at least we don't have three world class keepers competing for the one spot.

 

[not my fault!]

Given is great but he scares me. He's a great shot stopper but has poor distribution, where as hart commands his area and can pick a player out. As young as he is I think he's ready to be the city legend we all know he's capable of being!

 

[Xyplode]

Hart

 

[cleavers]

We're building for the future, Given is the past, he will get plenty of games, but Hart is the future, if we let him go (even on loan) its madness.

 

[Peter Doherty]

Given is a given...