Half-Term Player Rating..

[Zickler]

Nearly halftime in the season, how would you score the lads individual perfomances so far this season?

 

[es1]

i think you have to start this off by supplying your own ideas for player ratings!

 

[Zickler]

5/10 = Toure, Ned, Silvy

6/10 = Zab, Ireland, Petrov, Richards, Lescot, Taylor, VW, RSC, Ade, Bridge, Robi

7/10 = NDJ, Barry,

8/10 = Given, Tevez

9/10 = Bellers ( top student so far)

 

[es1]

5/10 = Toure, Ned, Silvy

6/10 = Zab, Ireland, Petrov, Richards, Lescot, Taylor, VW, RSC, Ade, Bridge, Robi

7/10 = NDJ, Barry,

8/10 = Given, Tevez

9/10 = Bellers ( top student so far)

i think its harsh to mark ned as a 5 given that he's hardly played

I think njd should an 8 (at least) given tevez and bellamy i agree with

you cant mark taylor as he has not played!

however i agree with all your other '6' ratings

 

[Polari]

5/10 = Toure, Ned, Silvy

6/10 = Zab, Ireland, Petrov, Richards, Lescot, Taylor, VW, RSC, Ade, Bridge, Robi

7/10 = NDJ, Barry,

8/10 = Given, Tevez

9/10 = Bellers ( top student so far)

Agree with these except I'd put Barry on 6, Petrov on 7 (when he's played he's been excellent) and would put De Jong on 8. Don't know if Ned or Robi have played enough for a rating and I don't think Taylor has played a minute has he?

 

[Grand Master Ram Rod]

9 - Given, NDJ, Bellamy
8 - Bridge, SWP, Tevez
7 - Ireland, Petrov, Barry, Lescott
6 - Richards, Zabaleta, Adebayor, Toure, Kompany
5 - Onuoha, Johnson, Robinho, RSC, Benjani, Weiss
4 - Sylvinho

 

[Dave Ewing's Back 'eader]

5/10 = Toure, Ned, Silvy

6/10 = Zab, Ireland, Petrov, Richards, Lescot, Taylor, VW, RSC, Ade, Bridge, Robi

7/10 = NDJ, Barry,

8/10 = Given, Tevez

9/10 = Bellers ( top student so far)

I would give Ireland and Ned 6.5 but I'm pretty much the same with those marks. Leaves plenty of scope for 2010, and I am certain they will rise to the challenge.

 

[Fulop's Reflex]

8 :Bellamy
7 :Given, Ade, Tevez, NJD and Petrov.
6 :Defenders, Robinho, Superman, Barry, SWP and Zabaleta

 

[bananamilksheikh]

8 :Bellamy
7 :Given, Ade, Tevez, NJD and Petrov.
6 :Defenders, Robinho, Superman, Barry, SWP and Zabaleta

so you rate Teves and Given the same as Ade? Specsavers?

 

[Fulop's Reflex]

8 :Bellamy
7 :Given, Ade, Tevez, NJD and Petrov.
6 :Defenders, Robinho, Superman, Barry, SWP and Zabaleta

so you rate Teves and Given the same as Ade? Specsavers?

The OP asks us to rate the players in Half-term season, not 3-4 games.