Hart - Do we want him back or not? [Merged]

[schumey04]

...... Do we really want a player back who blatantly doesnt want to play for us

<a class="postlink" href="http://www.sport.co.uk/news/Football/38117/I_didnt_really_want_to_leave_but_I_was_told_I_have_to.aspx" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://www.sport.co.uk/news/Football/38 ... ve_to.aspx</a>

I have heard rumours in the club that Shay will not play again and if he does he will be a shadow of his former self. Should we just bite the bullet and spend money on a new worldclass keeper or hope that Hart does the job?

What do you think???

 

[KentBlue]

Re: Hart do we really want him back

I'd take that with a pinch of salt. I'll believe it when and if Joe himself comes out and says it.

 

[Uwe's 80s mullet]

Re: Hart do we really want him back

im 100% certain he does want to play for us but he is worried because shay given is currently no1. so no we would be fucking bonkers to sell the future england keeper.

if i had my way he'd be our no1 from now on.

 

[Blue Coop]

Re: Hart do we really want him back

Shay has had a few injuries with that shoulder now i believe, and to be confident diving to his left again could take some time. I wouldn't want to see a Buffon come in who is much older, but perhaps a Lloris who has many years ahead of him and ha shad an outstanding season. (Perhaps more so that Hart)

Why would Hart not want to play again. Because we loaned him out? Arguebly the reason that he is now probably englands number one is the fact that we loaned him out and he has performed well. It could have been a different story in our goal.

 

[Seosa]

Re: Hart do we really want him back

He's been quietly negative towards City a few times this season, i.e. reffering to City as 'them', saying how he'd cheer Brum if we'd have met in the Cup final etc, I still think we could do better, but dont let the wets hear me say that...

 

[Marvin]

Re: Hart do we really want him back

Voted best keeper in the Premiership by the PFA

I don't know what hart is rumoured to have said about playing for ity but suspect he just wanted to play 1st team football. Move has been good for him, and City as he has improved

 

[Dave Ewing's Back 'eader]

Re: Hart do we really want him back

He's been quietly negative towards City a few times this season, i.e. reffering to City as 'them', saying how he'd cheer Brum if we'd have met in the Cup final etc, I still think we could do better, but dont let the wets hear me say that...

Joe Hart is a decent goalkeeper but not another Trautmann. Shay will have a question mark over him, and I wouldn't be surprised if he wasn't ready for start of the season. Buffon has badmouthed us and I wouldn't give 'im a spare sheet of bogpaper. From having two decent keepers it has developed into a bit of an issue

 

[Seosa]

Re: Hart do we really want him back

He's been quietly negative towards City a few times this season, i.e. reffering to City as 'them', saying how he'd cheer Brum if we'd have met in the Cup final etc, I still think we could do better, but dont let the wets hear me say that...

Joe Hart is a decent goalkeeper but not another Trautmann. Shay will have a question mark over him, and I wouldn't be surprised if he wasn't ready for start of the season. Buffon has badmouthed us and I wouldn't give 'im a spare sheet of bogpaper. From having two decent keepers it has developed into a bit of an issue

Heres 3 for starters: Akinfeev, Lloris and Cesar. Maybe not realistic, but we can live in hope

 

[schumey04]

Re: Hart do we really want him back

He's been quietly negative towards City a few times this season, i.e. reffering to City as 'them', saying how he'd cheer Brum if we'd have met in the Cup final etc, I still think we could do better, but dont let the wets hear me say that...

i suppose hes young and feels a little hard done by but loaning him out bettered his game city have brought him to this position. I'm just worried that we'll have another player moaning in the dressing room next season and thats the last thing we need

 

[Warwickhunt]

Re: Hart do we really want him back

I'd keep him, and if shay will have problems playing again, another young keeper i'd be looking to bring in would be manuel neuer.