Hart has to be back here next season

[flb]

Doesn't matter what given does between the sticks, he knows he will be starting the following game, Taylor must be useless, no competition.
Englands finest on loan at brum, fcuking diabolical!

This

 

[Sigster100]

OMFG I have seen it all now. If it wasn't for Shay we would have at least 10 points less than we have right now. Before Xmas he was like a one man defence and now people are calling for his head. So Delap's throw ins have not led to any golas against other teams have they not? Maybe we should be asking what the defenders were doing that allowed Shawcross to get a pretty free header in the first place. Maybe if we had not missed so many chances in the first 30 mins, we would not have lost. Shay is arguably the best keeper in the Premiership and although not perfect, I would not want anyone else between the sticks for us.
This is so typical of City fans with short memories of where we were inthe not too distant past. We have won nothing for 35 years and yet all of a sudden, if we don't get overnight success, all you hear is sack Mancini, get rid of Given, SWP is past it etc etc. Jeez, have some patience and try and support your team.

 

[calculated]

If we're insane enough to get rid of Given I guarantee he'll go on to a top 4 side, likely Arsenal. How quick some of you have forgotten how many points he earned us not so long ago.

 

[Carl_Man_City]

OMFG I have seen it all now. If it wasn't for Shay we would have at least 10 points less than we have right now. Before Xmas he was like a one man defence and now people are calling for his head. So Delap's throw ins have not led to any golas against other teams have they not? Maybe we should be asking what the defenders were doing that allowed Shawcross to get a pretty free header in the first place. Maybe if we had not missed so many chances in the first 30 mins, we would not have lost. Shay is arguably the best keeper in the Premiership and although not perfect, I would not want anyone else between the sticks for us.
This is so typical of City fans with short memories of where we were inthe not too distant past. We have won nothing for 35 years and yet all of a sudden, if we don't get overnight success, all you hear is sack Mancini, get rid of Given, SWP is past it etc etc. Jeez, have some patience and try and support your team.

rubbish, stopped reading there

 

[Sky Blue]

Shay is arguably the best keeper in the Premiership.

Just stop that. Not even close. I cringe when I hear or read it. Hart must come back next season.

 

[Halfpenny]

OMFG I have seen it all now. If it wasn't for Shay we would have at least 10 points less than we have right now. Before Xmas he was like a one man defence and now people are calling for his head. So Delap's throw ins have not led to any golas against other teams have they not? Maybe we should be asking what the defenders were doing that allowed Shawcross to get a pretty free header in the first place. Maybe if we had not missed so many chances in the first 30 mins, we would not have lost. Shay is arguably the best keeper in the Premiership and although not perfect, I would not want anyone else between the sticks for us.
This is so typical of City fans with short memories of where we were inthe not too distant past. We have won nothing for 35 years and yet all of a sudden, if we don't get overnight success, all you hear is sack Mancini, get rid of Given, SWP is past it etc etc. Jeez, have some patience and try and support your team.

Sense, finally.

For god's sake, he gets criticised for not coming off his line. He comes off his line and a goal is conceded, showing why it's a shit idea. He then gets lambasted anyway. Given is better than Hart right now, no question about it. God, I despair sometimes.

 

[Sigster100]

OMFG I have seen it all now. If it wasn't for Shay we would have at least 10 points less than we have right now. Before Xmas he was like a one man defence and now people are calling for his head. So Delap's throw ins have not led to any golas against other teams have they not? Maybe we should be asking what the defenders were doing that allowed Shawcross to get a pretty free header in the first place. Maybe if we had not missed so many chances in the first 30 mins, we would not have lost. Shay is arguably the best keeper in the Premiership and although not perfect, I would not want anyone else between the sticks for us.
This is so typical of City fans with short memories of where we were inthe not too distant past. We have won nothing for 35 years and yet all of a sudden, if we don't get overnight success, all you hear is sack Mancini, get rid of Given, SWP is past it etc etc. Jeez, have some patience and try and support your team.

rubbish, stopped reading there

And which bit exacty is rubbish?

 

[mcfc_nick]

For god's sake, he gets criticised for not coming off his line. He comes off his line and a goal is conceded, showing why it's a shit idea. He then gets lambasted anyway. Given is better than Hart right now, no question about it. God, I despair sometimes.

maybe if he came off his line at the right time and not when we have 2 defenders challenging for the ball and if the ball gets flicked on (like it did) he'd have had the simplest take.

 

[Carl_Man_City]

rubbish, stopped reading there

And which bit exacty is rubbish?

The bit in bold

 

[deakinblue]

Given isnt the complete goalkeeping package but neither is joe hart,I think we need to be looking for big strong keeper in the summer who will win those crossed balls.