Hart must play in the final

[franksinatra]

One of your worst efforts, and that's saying something.

I know, and I thought I needed attention in the media agenda thread. The guy has shown nothing over the past few years to suggest he deserves to represent Manchester City in a cup final. If I was Joe Hart I would be gutted to be missing a showcase final for a sub-standard keeper who has put in poor performances since the moment he has arrived at the club.

Now we are out of the FA cup, unlikely to win the Champs Leage and fourth in the league would it be fair after all Joe Harts efforts this year that he maybe denied a winners medal and Callabero gets one? Apparently so according to Marvin.

 

[super_city_si]

What a load of sentimental fucking shite. He deserves dropping because he's just had an absolute fucking mare. There is no comparison to Pants whatsoever. Pants had done nothing to deserve losing his spot, Willy has.

Exactly this. It's not like we're dripping with trophys. We're in this competition to win it, not to be nice guys. Willy is shit and if we sacrifice a good chance, nay our best chance of a trophy because we want to be nice to the backup goalie then what is the point?

He can't treat this like a Sunday league game where you play the guy who turned up the most as a reward. This is a profession. This is the final. Your backup goalie just had a mare. Drop him. Increase your prospect of winning. Easy.

 

[bobmcfc]

I can only blame him for the organisation of the defensive wall which was a shambles. I don't think the other goals were down to him. Indeed he made two great saves. The Cahill goal, the one that was at him was very difficult to save because it was low down. Only chance was to get a leg to it

Hart's our No. 1, but you have to have some loyalty to your players.

Do you not feel anything for the thousands of fans paying a fortune to go and watch us at Wembley ? He's a liability and not our best goalkeeper. He's just had a shocker and not his first btw.

 

[Marvin]

He was at fault for at least 3 goals. He made one decent save and stopped a lame pen. Apart from that it was one of the worst keeping displays I can remember.

I'd say he looked shaky and was at fault for one goal: the free-kick. That save in the 1st half was incredible. Stopped a certain goal, and the pen still took some stopping.

 

[Burtonblue]

Do you not feel anything for the thousands of fans paying a fortune to go and watch us at Wembley ? He's a liability and not our best goalkeeper. He's just had a shocker and not his first btw.

Well said Bob
I'm in for £300 so far for the day
Am feeling seriously concerned that it may be a poor investment!
I wouldn't mind if we didn't have better players as an alternative to Willy but bugger me we do!!
The thought of Joe sitting it out really bothers me...

 

[super_city_si]

I would hope someone higher up has heard pellegrinis insane ramblings and told him to give his a wobble and stfu. You're playing hart.

 

[Marvin]

Do you not feel anything for the thousands of fans paying a fortune to go and watch us at Wembley ? He's a liability and not our best goalkeeper. He's just had a shocker and not his first btw.

I know he's not our best keeper but you have to be fair to people and our players. He's a decent No. 2 and you have to give senior players something to play for.

 

[RandomJ]

We're weakening our chances of a trophy to stay loyal to a backup keeper who won't even fucking be here next season. I really hope someone steps in and tells Pellegrini to stop being a nob and pick Hart.

 

[carlosthejackal]

its a fucking cup final , a chance to win a trophy , you pick your best team simple as that .

 

[bobmcfc]

I'd say he looked shaky and was at fault for one goal: the free-kick. That save in the 1st half was incredible. Stopped a certain goal, and the pen still took some stopping.

as a footballer I'd say he's completely out of his depth. Has the reaction times of a snail on barbiturates, has zero positioning sense, doesn't know how to set up a wall, every time he dives for something it's more out of hope that awareness. He's like a talentless, second rate chancer who just woke up one day and decided he'd like try goal keeping.

 

[Cellarite]

I know he's not our best keeper but you have to be fair to people and our players. He's a decent No. 2 and you have to give senior players something to play for.

I think he's been fair allowing him to masquerade as a keeper for this long. He is handsomely paid to work for Manchester City. He has no loyalty to us and will be off in the summer. This is a cup final. We have to pick our best team and our best team includes Joe Hart.

 

[awest]

Willy is biz let's pack him off.

 

[Marvin]

Exactly this. It's not like we're dripping with trophys. We're in this competition to win it, not to be nice guys. Willy is shit and if we sacrifice a good chance, nay our best chance of a trophy because we want to be nice to the backup goalie then what is the point?

He can't treat this like a Sunday league game where you play the guy who turned up the most as a reward. This is a profession. This is the final. Your backup goalie just had a mare. Drop him. Increase your prospect of winning. Easy.

You will never have a No. 2 keeper then, or if you do it will be a Richard Wright.

Cabellero is not that bad a keeper. when we signed him he was widely regarded as the best keeper in La Liga and had some great games for Malaga

I don't recall anyone moaning about him when City beat Everton over two legs. One bad game and it's, "He's shit".

 

[RandomJ]

You will never have a No. 2 keeper then, or if you do it will be a Richard Wright.

Cabellero is not that bad a keeper. when we signed him he was widely regarded as the best keeper in La Liga and had some great games for Malaga

I don't recall anyone moaning about him when City beat Everton over two legs. One bad game and it's, "He's shit".

Hahahahahaha

 

[bobmcfc]

I know he's not our best keeper but you have to be fair to people and our players. He's a decent No. 2 and you have to give senior players something to play for.

picks up a better wage than I do so I'm sure he will be fine. Like others I'm £300 down on Wembley and want the best team out there. It's a big "fuck you" to the fans who are going down if he plays him over hart

 

[marshymcfc]

Hart has to start next Sunday!

 

[Gundogan's Moustache]

Liverpool saw how shit Bogdan is and dumped him , why can't we do the same?

It's almost like we're saying we know your shit but here's a chance to play once in a while

 

[Marvin]

I think he's been fair allowing him to masquerade as a keeper for this long. He is handsomely paid to work for Manchester City. He has no loyalty to us and will be off in the summer. This is a cup final. We have to pick our best team and our best team includes Joe Hart.

He is not our best keeper but I think if you have an understanding with a player you stick to it unless something extraordinary happens

A manager must respect his players.

 

[hateutd]

This will tell us a lot about Pellegrini. Realistically it's our only chance to win something. If he puts caballero in net he's a fucking nice guy loser. We have to play hart.

Agreed....but I still don't think we will win this final :(

 

[super_city_si]

You will never have a No. 2 keeper then, or if you do it will be a Richard Wright.

Cabellero is not that bad a keeper. when we signed him he was widely regarded as the best keeper in La Liga and had some great games for Malaga

I don't recall anyone moaning about him when City beat Everton over two legs. One bad game and it's, "He's shit".

He's not very good. He hasn't played one game where he has stood out. He was crap in the cup last year when we played boro and lost. We're playing Liverpool, a team we have had trouble playing against recently and our goalie will have to be on his game. Hart is the best one on one goalie in the league and is so much better than caballero. We can't afford to have caballero in net. This decision alone could be the difference between winning and losing the cup.