Hart or Neuer?

[salfordblues]

Would you swap our Joe for this guy?

I'd stick with Joe, however Neuer was fantastic last night and has real presence and confidence about him every time I see him play.

They will be in the top 2 in the world for years to come, if they aren't already.

 

[samharris]

Hart has prem experience Neuer doesnt tbh..

Thats why I'd have Hart.

 

[Blue>Red]

No, because you couldnt really separate them on talent, but joes english and theres 0 happier people than him on earth, an all round quality bloke

 

[GazC]

Joe's the best available in my eyes.

 

[grifter]

Neuer's marginally better but Hart is quality and english too so all things considered I'd rather have Hart.

 

[Ray78]

Tough one to call. Neuer has the honours but so did Eike Immell and we all know what happend there did we?

 

[bluemoon32]

Neuer didn't impress me last night, good during penalties but pretty shaky the rest of the game.

 

[Nelly's Left Foot]

Joe 100% ,silly question

 

[GazC]

Tough one to call. Neuer has the honours but so did Eike Immell and we all know what happend there did we?

Like Joe he's only won one domestic cup.

 

[Jay Division]

I'd say Neuer is slightly better than him, only because his distribution is second to none. But Hart every time for me. Such a top bloke to have around the squad, you can tell he loves it here and everyone in the team loves him, so for me, he is irreplaceable.