How do we resolve the Brexit mess?

Agreed, you have lost free movement BUT as has been pointed out before free movement means cheap labour for scrupulous businesses. It also led to wage drops for people doing manual labour type jobs. So, it becomes an issue of balancing the benefits against the negatives. So, in effect, the loss of free movement has improved the lives of the poorer end of the job market. Granted though, probably no advantage for the wealthier middle class and rich but let's not worry about them they have enough advantages in life as it is.
No it hasn’t minimun wage is still minimum wage, minimum wage jobs before brexit are still minimum wage jobs. People didn’t come from the EU and earn less than minimum wage.The lives of the poor paid are not better than they were. Everything in your post is false.
 
The SNP are the ruling party of Scotland. What is their reason for existing if not independence? It's utter crazy to suggest otherwise. Granted, Brexit has given them another 'bullet point' to highlight but I doubt it's affected anyones voting intentions on independence at all.
Northern Irelands problems pre date brexit by a long, long way. If someone can come up with a permanent solution where everyone is happy then I would vote for it. But that 'anyone' does not exist, do they? I listened to a radio caller from Northern Ireland on 5 Live the other day, despite the presenter trying to get brexit into his rant the caller did not bite. He said there had been and still were unfinished issues in NI from the last 25 years so Labour, Tory, Pre Brexit, Post Brexit have led to very little change. As I said, if you can fix NI permanently, I will vote for you.

I tend to vote based on long term expectations rather than short term benefits. So, I like to think, if I was in charge we would have been a lot further down the line with our climate response. So my brexit vote was based on my preference for minimum government and the predicted long term data. The long term data suggests it ends well in the end but possibly not in our lifetimes! Bit like buying a more efficient boiler, which costs more now, but over the course of it's life ends up paying for itself (if you live long enough of course).

I think the England, Scotland, NI and Wales seperated votes can, as always, be twisted at least two ways. Yes, Scotland and NI voted to Remain, but England and Wales voted to Leave. Surely the English Nationalists would be shit stirring rather than the Scots if we had Remained based on some convoluted voting system. The fact is always that more people voted Leave than Remain.
Nobody else suggested anything about the SNP, only your good self, and if you care to read the opinions of those living in Scotland in the Scottish politics thread, then you will see that many of their opinions and voting intentions have changed in light of the 2016 result. I agree, there have long been issues in Northern Ireland, but that was not the point. The point was whether Brexit was better for the U.K. and in Ulster’s case it’s has reopened wounds that were slowly, very slowly healing. As far as I can see, Brexit has not strengthened the United Kingdom politically.

As to whether it will be economically beneficial, that remains to be seen, but I’d certainly take any long-term predictions with a bucket load of salt. It’s over three years now since the U.K. could negotiate deals with countries and it has already been rebuffed by the country with whom it claims to have a special relationship and is nowhere near a deal with India or China, countries that harbour long-standing enmity to Britain. Without such deals, the country only becomes poorer. Your leaders hopelessly misread the tea leaves, on both sides of the debate. The U.K. was already in economic decline and, I suspect, its decision to leave will only accelerate that decline. The crumb of comfort seems to be the fact that it was the majority of people who rubber stamped the decision.
 
Last edited:
Right guys, I'm retiring from this thread. It's taking up too much of my time and raising my blood pressure too much. I've enjoyed debating/arguing with you all, keeps the mind active. I intend to spend a bit more time rearing unicorns on my farm 'Sunlit Uplands'.
Good luck in your search for an EU rule that no longer applies that has improved your life. Feel free to come out if retirement if you find one.
 
Agreed, you have lost free movement BUT as has been pointed out before free movement means cheap labour for scrupulous businesses. It also led to wage drops for people doing manual labour type jobs. So, it becomes an issue of balancing the benefits against the negatives. So, in effect, the loss of free movement has improved the lives of the poorer end of the job market. Granted though, probably no advantage for the wealthier middle class and rich but let's not worry about them they have enough advantages in life as it is.

EH? The people who are in demand because there is a shortage of labour have seen an increase so the likes of Aldi are paying £11.90p/h this year - the UK living wage is £9/90/h. Its still not a Kings Ransom and what you overlook is that they tend to employ people on 10-12 or 16hr pw contracts. Those people often get overtime so do earn a lot more - my daughter is often pressured by her employer to do extra hours even though overtime legally is voluntary.
So if they decide to shut where you work you may have been doing more than twice your contracted hours and getting say £20k pa out of them but the redundancy pay is based on your contracted hours which at Aldi - the best payers - that £9900. The employers jiggle the rules to suit themselves.
 
The offshoot Podcast from Alastair Campbell and Rory Stewart discussing Brexit (amongst other topics....but mainly Brexit) with Michel Barnier is a good listen:

 
Has Rory Stewart spoken out about his mate nadhim zahawai yet or is he still ignoring it?
 
No it hasn’t minimun wage is still minimum wage, minimum wage jobs before brexit are still minimum wage jobs. People didn’t come from the EU and earn less than minimum wage.The lives of the poor paid are not better than they were. Everything in your post is false.
The minimum wage is a sham, it is a typical neo liberal sop to the working class, that has been used as a baseline.

We had to leave to get away from this idiotic form of wage controls.

"A new draft EU law will ensure a minimum level of wage protection in all member states, in order to guarantee decent living standards for workers and their families.
In a vote on Thursday, MEPs on the Employment and Social Affairs Committee backed laying down minimum requirements to protect wages across the EU, either by establishing a statutory wage (the lowest wage permitted by law), or by allowing workers to negotiate their wages with their employers. The new legislation should apply to all workers in the EU who have an employment contract or employment relationship"

STATUTOURY WAGE, think about that.

It is not designed to help the working class, it is designed to help the Capitalist class keep wages at a level they can take the maximum surplus value from there employess
 
Given the option, I voted for what I believe is best for the UK and it's people. That's what democracy is, surely?
Do you believe everything Cameron, Osborne, May etc say? Weren't they Tory royalty?
No, I paid very little attention to Nigel Farage. Unlike yourself it seems, why do you people always bring up racism? I honestly find most people treat other people exactly as they find them. As for bigots, the irony, have a look at the dictionary definition and then have a look in the mirror.
Passport colour, seriously? What colour do you want it to be, personally I don't care?
We have a vote every 5 years, so if we choose, we can choose not to be governed by Eton old boys?
We have a vote every 5 years so we can vote in a government that protects workers rights to any level we want?
The worst bit is that the EU deserted you and left you stranded on a small independent island off Europe. I do think they could have done a lot, lot more for their loyal subjects who went into battle for them. I feel your pain at that rejection, they really have treated you like shit.
Yes, we will have a vote, will you be voting this lot out?
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.