Skashion said:
ElanJo said:
I don't think you'll find that the 'vocal' atheists, as you put it, are any different in that regard.
"I wander back and forth between atheism and agnosticism"
I don't think that makes sense. If you don't believe in a god then you're an atheist.
Like I said, people like Dawkins do. He talks of organising atheist political power to counter religious political power. To me any pro-secularist is welcome aboard the train of secularism, theist or not whereas Dawkins probably wouldn't make such allowances, him being on record as saying he prefers the fundamentalist of the opposition. That kind of shit is why I think he and others of his ilk are unreasonable.
So you don't believe there's such a thing as agnosticism?
But Dawkins doesn't.
"You can believe there is a creator without having any further beliefs whatsoever." He acknowledges this.
As for him helping out atheist and secular groups counter religious encroachment on the state (mostly in the US) I applaud him. What's wrong with that?
I have never seen Dawkins try to exclude religious secularists from the train of secularism. He may criticise them on the the veracity of their beliefs but that is a seperate issue.
With regards to agnosticism, if at no time do you wander into a belief in god you are at all times an atheist. You can be an agnostic atheist or a gnostic atheist just as you can be an agnostic theist or gnostic theist. A/gnosticism deals with knowledge. A/Theism deals with belief.
For instance, using my self as an example, I'm an agnostic atheist with regards to the notion that the universe was created by a deity.
I don't actively believe that the universe was created by a deity but
I don't claim to know that the universe was not created by a deity.
With regards to specific gods, such as the greek gods or the biblical god/s, and their descriptions, I am alot closer to a gnostic atheist, in that
I claim to know that these gods do not exist.*
*of course it depends how people describe their God. My basis for claiming knowledge here is the logical contradictory nature of many descriptions of god.