I posted this in the Title Race thread but it probably fits in this thread better…
…the only players in their prime years in our current squad even when everyone is fit are:
Akanji
Aké
Dias
Foden
Grealish
Haaland
Nunes
Rodri
…8 the 25 man squad, 32%, not even ⅓
I always think the very best teams have a majority of players in the squad in the 24-29 age bracket, with youngsters and ageing players supplementing that major group of players in their prime. Unless you have a situation where there are players over 30 who are still performing at the peak of their prime like Kompany, Fernandinho and David Silva did. And then they had De Bruyne, Bernardo Silva, Kun Agüero, Mahrez, Sterling, Stones, Walker, Ederson, Otamendi, Laporte, even Delph, all around them who were in their prime years.
That was 14 of the 25 man squad either in their prime or still performing at the level of their prime.
Youngsters and ageing players are over ⅔ of our entire squad, and the ageing midfield trio yesterday remind me more of the ageing four full backs we had under Pellegrini/Pep’s first season that really affected the way we played (and midfield is a more crucial area of the pitch than full backs) more than it did Fernandinho and DSilva in their 30s.
The average age of our midfield of Bernardo, Gündoğan and Kovačić was over 31 (31.3). Add de Bruyne to that midfield and the average age goes up. Then the average age of our outfield bench options (taking out de Bruyne who was never coming on) was under 20 (19.8).
The only players not available from all of the 24-29 year olds we have in the full squad are Dias, Grealish and Rodri but even just having those three out, that leaves us with just 5 players/20% of our entire squad being in their prime.
That sort of issue will be a factor with any squad. We don’t have enough players who are at the peak of both their ability+physicality combined to make a player the best they’ll be in their career.
Not only is either getting Pep to sign or finding his replacement important, but getting the balance of the amount of players in their prime in the squad is just as important. Unless we are aiming to build a young squad and forgo winning as much for a few years as De Bruyne, Gündoğan, Bernardo, Kovačić, Walker, Stones etc. all get older, unfortunately get worse and then leave/retire and we have a young crop of players who’ll take a few years to develop? But I thought we would manage our squad better than that to be more consistently elite.