"I Played For Man City Once You Know"

[lancs blue]

Ron Phoenix ??

And if you'd represented City at some level you would never have mentioned it of course. -- Wed Oct 24, 2012 5:37 pm -- Never heard of that (but it could be my memory) and I was regular at Maine Road 40 years ago. I guess Gary James would be the man with a definitive answer.

Thanks mate, prob my rag mate

40 years ago? Well the goals are fiction but Howard White made his debut against Liverpool in 1971 in a top flight match that was almost a ressies fixture, City had a number of injuries and both sides "rested" players ahead of key European matches. Crowd was less than 20k IIRC - White was carried off in the first half with a broken ankle or leg and never featured again in the first team.

 

[JGL07]

Ron Phoenix ??

Thanks mate, prob my rag mate

40 years ago? Well the goals are fiction but Howard White made his debut against Liverpool in 1971 in a top flight match that was almost a ressies fixture, City had a number of injuries and both sides "rested" players ahead of key European matches. Crowd was less than 20k IIRC - White was carried off in the first half with a broken ankle or leg and never featured again in the first team.

The match was on a Monday night with the ECWC Semi-Final second leg against Chelsea two days later. That made three matches in five days. Hence there were nine changes for the Liverpool match and a further eight changes for the Chelsea match.

 

[Mad Eyed Screamer]

Neil Lennon and Ian Thompstone

Do you know Ian?

He does mention his 100% scoring record from time to time ;-)

Never met him, just know he played for City once (as did Lennon)<br /><br />-- Fri Oct 26, 2012 12:26 am --<br /><br />

ive played with rhys day before he joined city back in the late 90's. he was a fabulous defender. i think he played for the first team a few times.

ps. (i havent played for city though)

No, Rhys didn't play for the 1st team, sorry!

 

[bluemarauder10]

I'm sure Bill Williams wouldn't go around claiming that he played for City. I played football with his son and have been coached by Bill - he is a big red and hates City as much as the next rag.

 

[LongsightM13]

I'm sure Bill Williams wouldn't go around claiming that he played for City. I played football with his son and have been coached by Bill - he is a big red and hates City as much as the next rag.

One of our most bizarre signings ever. A fat, slow, fourth division defender, not even a good player at his own level.

As for the other question, didn't Paul Hince get two on his debut, then got injured in his next game? Gary J is the man with the answers

 

[WEMBLEY76]

Barney Daniels scored a hat trick on his debut v Leicester in 1974 IIRC,didn't play many games after that

 

[Mad Eyed Screamer]

Barney Daniels scored a hat trick on his debut v Leicester in 1974 IIRC,didn't play many games after that

9 starts and 5 as a sub

 

[oakiecokie]

Alan Oakes brother happens to be my best mate and yes I know Alan and his cousin Glyn Pardoe.Glyn used to take me to City home games whilst he was playing as Citys centre forward when I was in my early teens,way back in the mid 1960s.
Used to be great,once he`d parked his car up on the Players and Staff Car Park behind the Platt Lane End and along would come Mike Doyle and Alan,as they`d all wait for one another to arrive before walking upto the Players Entrance.
Wonderful memorries travelling with Glyns Mum,Girlfriend (Pat who he marrried) and his Nan.

 

[Le Havre Oswald]

Wayne bridge.

Oh wait...



He's still here.

 

[Balti]

thought it said I PRAYED for City once you know

firk me I used to pray for us regularly in the dark days

 

[erast fandorin]

Pete Leigh,played couple of games 1960 and went on to captain Crewe for years

 

[AndyMorrison'sDietician]

Alfons Groenendijk, Paul Beesley, Carl Shutt..........God we've had some shit

 

[Big Swifty]

Hate to be a pedant, but Barney Daniels only scored two on debut, not three. I was there and he had a rocket shot. I thought we'd found the new Franny Lee. The trouble was, BD was bugger all use as a player.

 

[Alex the Blue]

I'm sure Bill Williams wouldn't go around claiming that he played for City. I played football with his son and have been coached by Bill - he is a big red and hates City as much as the next rag.

One of our most bizarre signings ever. A fat, slow, fourth division defender, not even a good player at his own level.

As for the other question, didn't Paul Hince get two on his debut, then got injured in his next game? Gary J is the man with the answers

Paul Hince scored 2 in 2 minutes during the 1st half on his debut against WBA. Typical City managed to draw the game 2-2 whilst we were all hoping this new superstar would bag a hat-trick

 

[liam81101]

Both Lennon and Thompstone's only appearance came within a few weeks of each other - Lennon's at Birmingham City and Thompstone's at Middlesbrough - both attended by yours truly (1987-88)

 

[Gary James]

Ron Phoenix ??

40 years ago? Well the goals are fiction but Howard White made his debut against Liverpool in 1971 in a top flight match that was almost a ressies fixture, City had a number of injuries and both sides "rested" players ahead of key European matches. Crowd was less than 20k IIRC - White was carried off in the first half with a broken ankle or leg and never featured again in the first team.

The match was on a Monday night with the ECWC Semi-Final second leg against Chelsea two days later. That made three matches in five days. Hence there were nine changes for the Liverpool match and a further eight changes for the Chelsea match.

Only just spotted this. Not much more to add really - both answers perfect. Howard White is possibly the guy this thread started off questioning.

He was a defender 1970-73, born in Manchester in 1954. He was brought into the first team due to City's injury situation at the time (Liverpool were punished for fielding a weakened team, City were viewed by the FL/FA as having no choice). The match was a rearranged League game and Howard had impressed in the reserve team (reserve debut on 6th March at Wolves).

The game ended 2-2. Attendance was 17,975. City scorers were Steve Carter and Ross (own goal)

Both clubs were ordered to produce medical evidence concerning their weakened teams. As I mentioned City were okay but Liverpool were fined for resting players who could have played. Howard White suffered a broken ankle just before half-time and that was the end of his League career. The rest of his City games were in the Reserves and junior. He moved to Bangor City on a free transfer in June 1973 after the solitary first team app and 44 (plus 1 as sub) reserve apps.

 

[City_Shirts]

Justin Fashanu !!!!!